68 pages • 2 hours read
Mary E. PearsonA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Throughout the novel, Pearson explores how political unrest among the kingdoms affects both communities and individuals. Political unrest disrupts life and safety in Hell’s Mouth in the wake of Karsen’s death, and Jase feels both the personal desire to protect his family's legacy and a moral obligation to his people. Similarly, the Rahtan’s mission to capture Illarion is motivated both by Queen Lia's personal vendetta and her desire to prevent future war. These two political aims work in tandem to divide Jase and Kazi’s loyalty and provide the framework of the plot.
The power vacuum created by the death of Jase’s father is immediately evident when Jase is captured by labor hunters in Hell’s Mouth. The Ballengers protect Hell’s Mouth and have never had problems with labor hunters because of their ruthless reputation. When Jase and Kazi make it back to civilization, Jase finds out the labor hunters are being paid to create unrest in Hell’s Mouth and tries to figure out who is doing it. The Vendan settlement is another piece of political unrest in the region. The Queen of Venda worked out the settlement with the King of Eislandia after the war, but they were placed near a Ballenger memorial, deepening the insult of their being positioned on unrecognized Ballenger land. After the settlement is raided, the Ballengers are an easy assumption as the culprits, but they didn’t do it. The attack was calculated to bring the kingdoms down on the Ballengers, so the political unrest of the region goes a lot deeper than Jase realized, and his family is being targeted specifically. Illarion attempts to exploit this political instability by developing an arsenal of weapons with other fugitives to put the kingdoms under his thumb. Jase doesn’t know this and helps him thinking only of protecting Hell’s Mouth; his good intentions and personal desire for a fever cure inadvertently contribute to the very political upheaval he's trying to stop. When Illarion's plot is revealed, Jase realizes how foolish his family has been and vows to do better.
In the end, the political instability of the realm is thought to be put to rest by the capture of the Illarion and his cohorts. The Queen of Venda agrees to support the Ballengers joining the Alliance of Kingdoms and being recognized as the First Kingdom on the continent because she recognizes that subjugating and ignoring the Ballengers enabled political instability to flourish in and around their territory. All the political unrest in the novel guides the character's motivation and plot, sets up the sequel, and contrasts the ideas of freedom and justice with the ideas of war, greed, and profit. Through Jase's benevolent leadership at the Vendan settlement and Queen Lia's graciousness at the end of the novel, Pearson suggests that political unrest is the result of unmet needs and exploitation. The solution proposed at the end of the novel is to prioritize the safety of communities over personal gain, and to seek compromise instead of domination.
The novel's plot centers on a secret mission, and the espionage Kazi and Jase engage is further complicated by their secret personal motives; through the many layers of deception and guarded truths, Pearson explores how secrecy alternately helps or hinders her characters' goals. The dual point-of-view allows readers to see Jase and Kazi’s motivations and how they are affected by their loyalties, without Kazi and Jase having to reveal these to one another. The secret motives add to the narrative tension of Jase and Kazi’s enemies-to-lovers relationship arc, suggesting that secrecy and intimacy are incompatible.
The Rahtan are sent to Hell’s Mouth to capture the traitor Captain Beaufort Illarion and bring him back to Venda. To do this, Kazi must hide her true purpose in Hell’s Mouth from Jase—both her official mission and her personal desire for redemption. She keeps him at arm’s length because she doesn’t want to screw everything up, and this only grows more complicated as she develops feelings from him. The first secret—the mission—leads to more secrets, as Kazi fears that succeeding at her goal will make a relationship with Jase impossible. Every lie she tells makes the truth more difficult to reveal.
Similarly, Jase’s can’t fully trust Kazi even though he wants to. He has Kazi followed and remains suspicious of her motives in Hell's Mouth, even as he falls more in love with her. He also lies to her about knowing the man who kidnapped her mom because he wants to find out what Zane knows about the labor hunters in Hell’s Mouth for his own purposes. Kazi and Jase’s contrasting motives put pressure on their relationship because they can’t fully trust each other even though they want to. When their secret motives are revealed, they feel hurt, even though they've both committed similar acts of dishonesty with one another. It is only after the climactic showdown when Jase realizes Kazi's mission and Kazi recognizes he lied about Zane that their relationship becomes truly possible. Although they are both upset, they are finally able to be honest with one another and exchange espionage for real intimacy.
Kazi and Jase fall in love over the course of Dance of Thieves, but their love story is riddled with betrayal before they get their happily ever after. Over the course of the novel, Kazi and Jase learn that while love can make a person more vulnerable to the pain of betrayal, it is also stronger than fear or deception.
Kazi is afraid to love because of her past trauma over her mom being kidnapped. She grew up on the streets of Venda and saw how easily people could die and disappear, so she toughened her heart and decided not to love. It’s her survival tactic, so she resists falling for Jase at first. He wants tomorrows with her, but she can’t promise him that because she knows she must betray him out of duty to the Queen of Venda. Though Jase grew up in a loving family, he has a similar sense of duty and his first job is to protect his people. He initially sees Kazi as a threat to his family’s power and position, but the more he gets to know her, he falls in love, and he’s the first one to say I love you. His love slowly pushes Kazi out of her hardened shell, and he’s the one to risk his heart first and put his life on the line for her. However, he doesn’t completely trust her and lies to her about knowing her mom’s kidnapper. Unlike Kazi, Jase doesn't consider this as a betrayal until it's too late. He plans to tell her when he thinks the time is right, but he fails to see how keeping the secret at all is a betrayal of her trust.
When their mutual betrayals are revealed Kazi and Jase they think their relationship is done: “His lie about Zane left me raw, and I saw the bitterness in his eyes too, when he caught me at the enclave. Our mutual betrayals had shattered anything we once had” (446). However, their regard and love for each other is strong, and Kazi bridges the gap between them by advocating for Jase in front of the queen. Jase responds by asking her to come home with him. They forgive each other and agree to no more secrets to repair their relationships, showing that love can overcome betrayal if people forgive and agree to trust in the future.
By Mary E. Pearson