28 pages • 56 minutes read
Zora Neale HurstonA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
In the story, race and economic class play an important role because they provide context for the social paradigms in which these characters exist. Grandma Potts, as an elder in her community, would have been exposed to the harsh realities of racism, poverty, and the prejudices African Americans experience on a daily basis. As such, Grandma Potts fixates on appearances, and she wants to appear put together and proper to keep prejudice and violence at bay. When Isis goes missing at the carnival, Grandma Potts is concerned that she will “find her in her soiled dress, shoeless, gaping at the crowd,” which would violate the image she is trying to project about her family (51). Overt racial prejudice is not present in the text, but the story takes place in Florida during the Jim Crow era. This implies that Grandma Potts is familiar with segregation and anti-Black violence. Unlike Grandma Potts, Isis’s experience of the outside world is limited, and Isis appears sheltered from these realities because of her confinement within her home. Although Hurston does not explicitly state Grandma Potts’s background, her actions and expectations imply that she is looking to help her granddaughter go through life as easily as possible due to the discrimination against African Americans.
With this, the white shell road represents two conflicting viewpoints. Isis views it as her way to experience and explore the world, while Grandma Potts does not have the same fascination with it because of her knowledge of racial and class discrimination. The narrator claims that Isis’s love for sitting on the gate post to watch the road “[heaps] kindling on Grandma Potts’ already burning ire” (45). Grandma Potts understands the threats that go along with being out in the world, whereas Isis has yet to develop or experience racism. Her innocence in that regard is embodied in her childlike spirit; she approaches the world with wonder and trust. Grandma Potts’s practical nature cannot accept Isis’s obsession with leaving home, as she seems to be content existing within the boundaries of their property. This reflects Black feminist thoughts on the value of a safe home for Black people in a racist world; on this subject, bell hooks reflected that “Black women resisted by making homes where all black people could strive to be subjects, not objects” (“Homeplace (a site of resistance)” Yearning: Race, gender, and cultural politics. South End Press, 1990, pp. 41-49).
Helen, a rich, white woman, leads a different existence from Isis and her family. She has the ability to spend five dollars replacing Grandma Potts’s tablecloth and taking Isis along with her to Maitland. Once she offers her the money, Grandma Potts quickly accepts, “Oh, yessum, yessum […] Everything’s alright, sho’ she kin go, yessum” (54). Despite her wish to control Isis and her behaviors, Grandma Potts easily accepts this trade. Not only does the five dollars cover the price of the tablecloth, but it also provides her with extra funds that benefit the family. With this, Hurston strikes an uneasy balance between Grandma Potts’s desire to protect her granddaughter and provide for her more literally. The presentation of race and class in the story enables Hurston to give context to her characters’ decisions, as their social status affects every aspect of their daily lives.
In the story, the community allows Isis to feel a sense of connection with those around her. At the beginning of the story, Isis sits atop the gate post to watch the cars drive by and connect with people like the Robinson brothers. For Isis, she cherishes the moments she spends with those around her. The narrator says, “Everybody in the country, white and colored, knew little Isie Watts, the joyful. The Robinson brothers, white cattlemen, were particularly fond of her” (46). Both Isis and the surrounding community enjoy each other’s company, and the road provides an outlet for humanity to come together despite their differences. Without these interactions, Isis would be limited to her familial relationships. Isis values these interactions with other people, especially since she receives positive attention for dancing and playing. The community also provides Isis with an escape from her grandmother’s disciplinarian presence.
At the carnival, Isis plays out her fantasies by creating a spectacle of herself through dancing. Isis exudes a larger-than-life presence that commands attention, which provides her with opportunities to engage with other children and adults. Despite being dressed in a tablecloth, Isis feels as though she is the princess in her daydreams because of the excitement and happiness within the carnival’s environment. Her jubilance is infectious, and the text notes how all eyes are on Isis even when important people try to capture the crowd’s attention. The carnival emerges in a moment of crisis when Isis is about to be punished, indicating how this demonstration of community figuratively heals Isis.
The sense of community allows the characters to have meaningful experiences. It brings together all people in the area to celebrate, regardless of their different life experiences and social classes. Helen and her friends’ presence alongside Grandma Potts demonstrates the breadth of the community. Hurston emphasizes how this is important for everyone and not just Isis with the band marching down the road. Finally, this community creates another opportunity for Isis to make friends and experience the world; without the carnival, she would not end up in the backseat with Helen. While it’s unclear whether Maitland is a positive destination for Isis, this chance for exploration and growth exists because Isis connects with others.
Throughout the story, Isis begins a coming-of-age arc, and she attempts to establish her own identity outside of the expectations Grandma Potts has placed on her. As a young girl, Isis is not only developing her sense of self but her understanding of the world. She spends her time “imagining herself various personages” to escape the constricting expectations Grandma Potts puts on her (48). Rather than adhering to gender stereotypes and limiting her life within their family home, Isis aspires to be a strong, adventurous person. Her grandmother expects her to behave as a stereotypical lady who does not “sit with the knees separated” or play with boys (47). Grandma Potts and Isis follow two different ideologies, and as a young child, Isis must adhere to the traditional, conservative values that her grandmother promotes while she is under her care.
According to her grandmother, Isis must be a domestic caretaker who tends to the house. However, Isis would rather spend her time playing with dogs and acting out heroic tales. She tells Helen of the time she was Hercules and fought “numerous dragons and sundry giants” (52). The image of slaying dragons and giants contrasts with stereotypical feminine daydreams. Rather than confining herself to simple masculine or feminine characters, Isis pictures herself as both a princess and Hercules. By doing so, she creates her own version of girlhood that encapsulates both feminine and masculine qualities. The identity she envisions is truly hers, existing outside the gender binary and stereotypical gender norms.
By naming Isis after an Egyptian goddess, Hurston implies that her protagonist will grow into a strong woman. Isis develops a presence that enthralls those around her, and she feeds off the others’ attention. Isis mirrors the goddess and exudes her own magic and healing properties when the community circles around her to watch her dance: “A crowd of children gathered admiringly about her […] Some grown people joined the children about her. The Grand Exalted Ruler rose to speak; the band was hushed, but Isis danced on, the crowd clapping their hands for her” (50). Not only does the importance of community come into the scene, but Hurston also illustrates how Isis’s personality and charisma bring her to the center of attention. She commands the space and discovers joy in bringing happiness to others around her. In this moment, Isis appeals to her community and can act as her true self rather than constricting her behaviors to please her grandmother.
By Zora Neale Hurston