logo

65 pages 2 hours read

Paulo Coelho

Eleven Minutes

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 2003

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Literary Devices

Shifting Point-of-View/Gossiping with the Reader

Reading the first third of Eleven Minutes from the beginning would cause a reader to assume that Coelho is writing from the third person point of view (POV), which focuses completely on his main character, Maria. Though most of the narrative is written from this viewpoint, the author does break away periodically to write from the perspective of other characters, most notably Terence the English music executive in Chapter 23 and Heidi the widowed librarian in Chapter 31. His intention in shifting his POV is to explore topics that exceed the interest or expertise of the main characters and do not directly advance the progression of the story. It is as if the author is saying Maria would not be able to understand this, but Terence would. For instance, Coelho wants to unpack the subject of BDSM from an objective perspective. In achieving this, he has to resort to writing from Terence’s viewpoint because Maria has just been immersed in the experience and, in her relative ignorance, she is struggling to understand this new world. Neither can he objectively write it from Ralf’s viewpoint since, in the following two chapters, Ralf will seek to undermine the legitimacy of the BDSM lifestyle. Coelho must adopt a shifting POV if he is to unpack these aspects of sexuality.

As a part of his third person POV, Coelho is also able to gossip with his readers. This technique is also used by some well-known English language writers like T. B. White in his epic The Once and Future King, or C. S. Lewis in The Chronicles of Narnia. This technique is characterized by an author who, in the midst of telling a story, suddenly writes an editorial comment as an aside intended for readers. For instance, in Chapter 12, Coelho comments about Maria’s first full night of sex work: “She was doing it because she needed to. This wasn’t quite true—everyone needs to earn money, but not everyone chooses to live on the margins of society” (75). In this passage, Coelho is standing apart from the character he is creating to speculate along with his readers about Maria’s decision—why she made it and what it means going forward. Such gossiping creates a layer of intimacy between the author and reader and allows the author to depart from the strict storyline to editorialize about the characters.

The Use of Wisdom Proverbs

Another characteristic of Coelho’s writing is the inclusion of proverbial sayings. In other types of writing, these are called “wisdom literature” and take the form of proverbs the author places appropriately at points in the narrative to comment on the characters’ experiences, challenges, or decisions. For example, when the full realization of the terms of her contract to be a samba dancer comes to light, Maria realizes Roger has tricked her. Coelho writes, “she was beginning to understand that […] when it came to seductions, feelings and contracts, one should never play around” (31).

Many of these proverbs are shared in Maria’s voice, as written in her diary. For instance, through one of Maria’s diary entries, Coelho expresses the timeless realization that relationships and possessions are never fully owned: “Anyone who has lost something they thought was theirs forever […] finally comes to realize that nothing really belongs to them” (26). This becomes such a mantra for Maria she repeats it to herself as one of the guiding principles of her life and the one main rule that makes her decide never to fall in love.

Maria’s Diary as the Moral to Each Fable

The chorus in ancient Greek plays is a group of people often at the fringes of the action who speak as one and comment on the play that is taking place. In a similar way, fables like those attributed to Aesop, typically end with a lesson intended to provide a principle for living. Fiction writers have often found ways to end their work with a moral saying. Even Shakespeare ended plays, such as Romeo and Juliet, with judgmental comments that could be called morals. With Eleven Minutes, Coelho regularly expresses his insights and judgments in the words of Maria’s diary entries, which always come at the end of a chapter.

For example, in Chapter 25 Ralf provides Maria with an overview of the history of both economic prostitution and religious prostitution. These learnings force her to face her unsettled feelings about being a sex worker, a process she works through in her diary. However beyond merely expressing her dissatisfaction with what she is doing, she also places a judgment or moral upon prostitution, saying:

I cannot simply do nothing, pretend that everything is normal, that it’s just a stage, a phase of my life. I want to forget it, I need to love—that’s all, I need to love. Life is too short, or too long, for me to allow myself the luxury of living it so badly (206).
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text