60 pages • 2 hours read
Michael LewisA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
One of the only FTX employees who remained in the Bahamas was Constance Wang, the COO of FTX and the CEO of FTX Digital Markets. She remained partly because she was unable to transport both her cats home to China. Her friend and subordinate Quinn Li stayed to help her. Constance was also motivated by a desire to find out what had happened to FTX.
Constance obtained and reviewed a stack of company documents. One of the documents revealed that over $10 billion of customer funds had been misappropriated—the money had been moved into Sam’s personal trading fund.
Lewis describes how FTX had risked traders’ money. FTX had loaned Alameda all its customer deposits for free. It had also excused Alameda from following the same risk rules it imposed on all other traders on its platform. While trades that went into the red were normally liquidated, Alameda was given special treatment and allowed to hold onto losing positions indefinitely.
Constance also reviewed a document that showed the top shareholders of FTX. Even though she had been one of FTX’s earliest employees and had served as an executive of the company, she only owned 0.04% of the company, less than virtually all other employees at her level. Constance felt angry and betrayed.
Over the next month, she attempted in various ways to piece together the true extent of the deception and misappropriation at FTX. She wanted to pull a confession out of Sam. Sam explained to Constance that Alameda was allowed to function without risk limits because Alameda was FTX’s biggest trader, responsible for the majority of the platform’s trading volume, and so allowing Alameda to run losses helped the exchange maintain liquidity. Most of the customer funds that were in Alameda when they should have been in FTX were stored in an Alameda account called “fiat@.” Sam claimed that the funds had accumulated in this account because FTX was not able to get approved for a traditional bank account until 2021, and so customer funds piled up in the Alameda account and were never moved. However, Sam also told Constance that he wasn’t aware that this was the case because Caroline was the one who oversaw Alameda, not him.
Constance tried her best to catch Sam in a contradiction or reveal any evidence of intentional wrongdoing, but she was frustrated in her attempts. Her main takeaway was that, in the aftermath of all this chaos, Sam didn’t seem to realize the gravity of his actions or the harm caused to investors and employees. Constance believed he had “zero empathy...He can’t feel anything” (223).
Lewis tried to use rough math to figure out what had happened to the missing money. He created a list of money in and money out, treating FTX and Alameda Research as one unit: “Sam's World” (223). In the end, he determined that $6 billion in total was missing.
Lewis outlines a few possible explanations for the missing funds: Alameda traders might have lost the money through risky trades, or the collapse of the cryptocurrency market could have resulted in significant losses. However, he claims that neither of those are adequate explanations for the magnitude of the missing funds.
When Lewis asked Sam directly about the missing money, Sam claimed that about $1 billion was lost to hackers. Sam and Gary had kept these hacks quiet so as not to incentivize further hacking attempts. Sam offered Lewis no explanation for the other $5 billion in missing funds. He believed that the situation was similar to that of the missing Ripple, sure that the money would somehow turn up.
On December 12, Sam’s lawyers called and informed him that the US government was giving Sam an ultimatum: He had one hour to make plans to return to the US. If he didn’t, he would be arrested in the Bahamas. Sam hurriedly composed his written testimony, hoping he could make a deal that would allow him not to be detained by the US, but he didn’t finish within the hour. The Bahamian police arrested him.
While the police carried out the arrest, Constance and Quinn entered the apartment and tried to help Sam by packing his clothes. Constance spotted Manfred, Sam’s stuffed animal that he carried everywhere. Constance believed that Sam felt a strong emotional attachment to Manfred, and that Sam loved the toy so much that Manfred might accompany Sam to jail.
In the final chapter, Lewis introduces John Ray, a specialist in recovering money from collapsed companies, who was tasked with taking over FTX as CEO after the company filed for bankruptcy. Ray was brought on by Sullivan & Cromwell, a law firm that had previously served FTX. After Ray was appointed CEO, he hired Sullivan & Cromwell to handle FTX’s bankruptcy proceedings.
Ray liked to make snap judgments. He categorized people as either good, naive, or criminal, and he believed that Sam was a criminal. He didn't trust Sam and refused to talk to him. Ray instead conducted his own investigation of FTX. He interviewed and fired most of the employees at FTX and Alameda.
Ray uncovered evidence that he thought pointed to crimes. However, Lewis claims that these allegations may not be as clear-cut as Ray believed. Lewis argues that his access to Sam and his inner circle afforded Lewis a much deeper understanding of the situation, and he provides alternative explanations for some of the actions that Ray saw as criminal. Lewis implies that Ray’s snap judgments and refusal to engage with Sam may have hindered his ability to fully grasp the complexities of the situation and make informed decisions.
Ray discovered what he believed to be evidence that FTX had smothered whistleblower complaints. Lewis claims that this evidence has a reasonable explanation: According to his conversations with Nishad, several disgruntled, fired employees tried to “shake down” (238) FTX by threatening to make false accusations against the company. Instead of risking bad publicity, FTX decided to quietly pay off these employees, in a strategy they nicknamed Operation Warm Blanket. Lewis does not account for the fact that whistleblowers are often accused of being disgruntled and acting for revenge—this is a standard line of company defense.
Ray and his team determined that FTX owed customers $8.6 billion. To recover this money, Ray decided to “claw back” (241) money Sam had given to other people—a technical term for reclaiming funds that were obtained in a criminal way. To do this, Ray filed lawsuits against various individuals and entities connected to Sam, seeking to recoup donations and investments they had received from FTX.
Dan Friedberg, FTX’s general counsel, raised concerns over Sullivan & Cromwell’s conflict of interest in controlling the bankruptcy proceedings for FTX, but was ignored. Instead, since Ray believed Friedberg to be a criminal, Ray brought a lawsuit against him. Ray claimed that FTX granted Friedberg over one hundred million tokens of Serum (a cryptocurrency created by an organization called the Solana Foundation) in 2020, which were now worth over $33.7 billion. However, Lewis claims that Friedberg’s Serum was actually not worth that much.
After six months of investigating, Ray recovered about $7 billion. Lewis argues that this shows that the money was never missing: “It was still there” (247).
Sam’s bail amount was set at $250 million. His parents posted their house as collateral to cover his bail. When Sam made bail, the public saw it as evidence of his ability to still access significant financial resources, which Lewis implies may have falsely contributed to the perception that Sam’s actions were criminal in nature. He claims that those who viewed Sam at a distance held a black-and-white view of Sam’s criminality, but that those close to him knew there must be more to the story.
Caroline, Gary, and Nishad pleaded guilty to financial crimes, but Sam insisted on his innocence. Awaiting trial, Sam stayed with his parents in his childhood home, an ankle monitor affixed to his leg. As a form of security, his parents bought him a large German shepherd that was trained to kill when given a command in German. Sam had no interest in the dog and did not bother learning the command words. Lewis notes how dangerous it was to have a trained attack dog in Sam’s presence, potentially posing a threat to his safety and the safety of others: It “would have been very Sam Bankman-Fried to have been eaten by his own guard dog” (251).
Lewis describes visiting the FTX headquarters in the Bahamas six months after the collapse. Many former employees described their experience working for FTX as dreamlike—that it was difficult to believe it had happened. In the Bahamas, Lewis searched for a particular item. In an unmarked shed in an unassuming storage facility, Lewis found what he was looking for: the tungsten cube.
These chapters explore the critical question of where the missing money went. While Lewis devotes much of this section to this question, building the mystery throughout, he ends on a somewhat anticlimactic conclusion: that the money was never missing. Despite his detailed refutation of other theories, Lewis does not provide many specifics when coming to this conclusion. Lewis’s wholesale acceptance of Sam’s innocence has resulted in critique—while praising Lewis’s typically excellent storytelling, reviewers wonder at the ways in which he seems to have lost objectivity in covering his subject.
Lewis continues to depict Sam as childlike. He describes Sam’s favorite stuffed animal, Manfred: “He’d had it since birth and refused any substitutes, and so Manfred was about to turn thirty-one years old […] Even then, Manfred was so old and worn it was hard to determine his species” (230). Sam, a grown man, is depicted as having such a deep attachment to this stuffed animal that his colleague speculated it may accompany him to jail. By the end of the book, Sam is shown in his parents’ house, as if grounded—though the reason for his stay was more serious; he wore an ankle monitor and was considered a flight risk. Still, the image of Sam confined to his parents’ home evokes the sense of a childlike figure.
In these chapters, Lewis continues to assert himself as someone with exclusive, insider access to Sam and FTX. He juxtaposes himself with Ray, the CEO who succeeded Sam. He depicts Ray as ignorant and bumbling, someone who is not privy to the same knowledge and understanding as Lewis:
To John Ray it felt like an Easter egg hunt. To me it felt more like an amateur archaeologist had stumbled upon a previously unknown civilization […] But the pleasure Ray took in whatever he unearthed was so infectious that I often didn’t have the heart to say, “I’m not quite sure that you’ve found exactly what you think you have found,” or “I actually know what that is, and it isn’t what you think” (238).
Lewis sees himself as someone who possesses vital insights that can provide a more nuanced perspective on the unfolding events, while Ray’s actions and judgments are depicted as ill-informed.
Lastly, in the coda, the tungsten cube serves as a symbol. Depicted in earlier chapters as perhaps a figment of the imagination, Lewis shows the tungsten cube to be real—if a useless and not particularly visually interesting marker of wealth and status in crypto circles. Its vague unreality matches the feelings of former FTX employees that their time at the company felt dreamlike. Lewis correlates the cube with FTX itself, implying that the fantastical events that transpired within the company really happened, despite how far-fetched they may appear to be.
By Michael Lewis
Books on U.S. History
View Collection
Business & Economics
View Collection
Challenging Authority
View Collection
Inspiring Biographies
View Collection
Mystery & Crime
View Collection
Order & Chaos
View Collection
Philosophy, Logic, & Ethics
View Collection
Power
View Collection
Science & Nature
View Collection
Teams & Gangs
View Collection
Trust & Doubt
View Collection