logo

53 pages 1 hour read

Liane Moriarty

Nine Perfect Strangers

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 2018

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Chapters 17-32Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Chapters 17-20 Summary

Frances is surprised that she agreed to go on a meditative hike at 8am. She’s even more surprised that she’s enjoying the experience, especially in contrast to the ever-more-rapid pace of modern life. While Frances is lost in her thoughts, Heather nearly walks off a steep cliff. Despite the near accident, neither Zoe nor Napoleon says anything. The hike continues.

Later that day, Tony Hogburn returns to his room. He’s angry and cynical about the constant silence and meditation at the spa. Still mired in grief following the loss of his beloved dog Banjo, Tony is also ashamed that the small amount of exercise has left him so exhausted. He isn’t close to his children, grandchildren, or ex-wife, but a recent medical diagnosis has meant that he has little time left. He feels a need to change, but his optimism about the spa is quickly fading. Still, he feels embarrassed by his interaction with Frances at the side of the road. Like his ex-wife, she made him feel like an “amateur human being” (105). He laughs in disbelief when his shorts no longer fit; as a former professional athlete, he has never thought of himself as overweight. He walks to the swimming pool and passes the middle-aged woman in the hallway. After deciding that she’s a “left-wing feminist” (106), he notices that she’s crying. At the pool, he’s horrified to see that Frances is already swimming.

In the pool, Frances curses Tony’s arrival. In her mind, he’s still labeled as the serial killer. She feels stuck in the pool because she doesn’t want “to get out in front of him” (107), as she neurotically thinks about him judging her body. She’s determined to enjoy the pool on her own terms. With her mind still thinking about the review, she’s aggravated when Tony breaks the noble silence. However, he points out that she has a nosebleed. To her horror, he tries to help her. As the bleeding subsides, she introduces herself and thanks him for his help. Tony awkwardly makes his excuses and leaves. As he walks away, his swimming shorts fall to reveal “two yellow smiley faces on both his butt cheeks” (110). Frances is amused and begins to alter her opinion of Tony the serial killer.

Masha is annoyed by another desperate email from her ex-husband. She’s determined to put aside her complicated, intruding emotions from the past and focus on her guests. Observing her guests on the CCTV system, she notices that Carmel Schneider—the middle-aged woman—is crying. Masha regrets that the guests’ rooms don’t have security cameras. Instead, she’s forced to listen to the audio. She hears Carmel telling herself to “get a grip” (112).

Chapters 21-24 Summary

For the first time in years, Carmel Schneider has time to herself. As much as she’s enjoying the chance to relax and lose weight, she can’t help but think about her four daughters. She worried about the girls, who are currently vacationing in Europe with her ex-husband and his fiancé. She fights to maintain her dignity even though her divorce makes her feel sad. Frances’s hair reminds Carmel of her husband’s fiancé, forcing her to return to her room in tears. She wants to be fitter and happier after attending the spa so that her ex-husband, Joel, will be shocked by her new appearance and regret his decision to leave her. She desperately wants to be changed by her experience at the spa, to be “someone other than this” (116). Her thoughts are interrupted by Yao, who brings an invitation to a spa treatment directly from Masha.

After dinner, Yao, Masha, and Delilah discuss the guests’ progress. As they talk, Yao watches Masha. He cares deeply for her, crediting her with saving his live, but he denies being in love with her. When Masha gave up her corporate career to dedicate herself to a wellness spa, Yao followed her after suffering a “major depressive episode” (120). Masha helped him recover, transforming him into a new person. Now, he tries to do the same for the guests. He sleeps with Delilah occasionally and always thinks about Masha.

On the fourth day of the retreat, Frances is surprised by how easily she has settled into the rhythm of life at Tranquillum House. Her cold symptoms disappear, and she feels more content being silent all the time. Zoe once passed her a chocolate, but other than that her social interactions have been scarce. She attends a one-on-one counselling session with Masha. They discuss Frances’s life, expectations, and desire to change. Masha shares her own experiences, such as the tragic death of her father and her immigration to Australia from Russia. Masha then reveals that the noble silence will end the next day but that a 24-hour fast will begin.

Carmel has a counselling session with Masha. Masha encourages Carmel to act in a more confident manner.

Chapters 25-28 Summary

Masha holds a counselling session with Tony. He admits that he feels as though he’s wasted much of his life “moping” (132). When Tony asks about Masha’s near-death experience, she’s reluctant to reveal too much. She already feels that she revealed too much to Frances. She lies to Tony, not telling him that her experience allowed her to see a grown-up version of her deceased son. Her self-improvement and reinvention were done for the young man she saw when she nearly died.

Napoleon enjoys the early morning tai chi sessions. On the fifth day, he takes part in a dawn session. He watches Heather and thinks about her sadness. After Zach’s death, she seems “broken.” He’s always tried to protect the fragile personality that lurks beneath Heather’s tough exterior, but he can’t seem to heal her grief. As the anniversary of Zach’s death approaches, he’s becoming more anxious. Napoleon blames the noble silence. He still remembers the day of Zach’s death and he blames himself for not saving his son. Zach died by suicide and left no note to explain his decision. He hanged himself with a belt, a Christmas gift from Heather. In the wake of Zach’s death, Napoleon resolved to “not break” so that he could support his wife, but the death created a vast gulf between them. As the tai chi session draws to a close, Napoleon feels his tears on his face.

Zoe notices her father’s tears. Like him, she still remembers her mother’s scream when Heather found Zach’s body. Zoe is surprised by the physicality of grief. She still resents her brother for inflicting this grief on her parents.

Heather doesn’t notice Napoleon’s tears. Instead, she remembers an incident from the previous week. Heather is a midwife, and, toward the end of a shift, she ran into the mother of one of Zach’s friends at the hospital. She unexpectedly exploded with anger at the woman and her son, both of whom apologized to her. Once again, Heather believes, she’d “turned the anger that should have been directed only at herself on someone else” (143).

Chapters 29-32 Summary

Frances takes part in the fast and looks forward to breaking the noble silence. She’s summoned to the meditation room, where candles and camp beds are laid out. Masha, Yao, Delilah, and the guests sit on the floor. The guests break the silence by introducing themselves to the group as they sip smoothies. Masha occasionally intervenes to keep the conversation on track, such as when Napoleon excitedly reveals that Tony is a famous legend of an Australian Rules football team. When Zoe talks freely about Zach’s death by suicide, Heather interrupts. She suspects that the smoothies contain some sort of medicine.

Masha regains control of her emotions after Zoe’s frank discussion of Zach’s death by suicide. She tries to avoid Heather’s accusation, but Heather becomes angry.

Lars listens with amusement as Masha admits to “micro-dosing” (153) the guests with the hallucinogenic drug LSD. Masha defends herself from the guests’ anger and confusion, claiming that they’ve been brainwashed by the government. The guests’ smoothies have been dosed with LSD all week, she explains, but their latest smoothie also contains “magic mushrooms” (155). Lars is delighted, though the other guests are angry and confused. As the drugs begin to take hold, the guests are encouraged to lay on the camp beds. Masks are placed over their eyes and headphones over their ears. As he lays down, Lars thinks about his life spent “eviscerating wealthy men who left their wives” (158) as his own way to get revenge against his father. He hallucinates a younger version of himself, trying to show him something.

Zoe watches her parents argue with the spa staff. As the drugs take effect, she talks to Zach’s voice in her head.

Chapters 17-32 Analysis

The animosity between Frances and Tony begins before they even arrive at Tranquillum House and continues throughout their first interactions. The noble silence allows this animosity to fester. The novel’s structure provides a different perspective in each chapter. Frances reveals her perception of Tony, while Tony shares his perception of Frances. The contrast between their perceptions and the reality that each character’s narration explores provides further characterization. Tony’s misreading of Francis, for example, reveals his own biases. He believes that she’s a left-wing feminist who will accuse him of boorish behavior. Frances has done nothing to provide evidence for this, but Tony’s assumption reveals his fear and his guilt. He believes that Frances might accuse him of this because he subconsciously believes it about himself. Frances’s fear that Tony will treat her as a foolish woman and discriminate against her speaks to her low sense of worth. Rejected by her publisher, scammed by her most recent romantic interest, and criticized in the press, Frances projects her self-loathing onto Tony, assuming that he’ll believe of her what she fears to be true. The silence ensures that neither of them can address this discrepancy. The animosity between Tony and Frances will eventually resolve, but the way in which it develops shows how the novel uses structure and perspective to compare the characters’ fears and assumptions.

Heather, Napoleon, and Zoe are all motivated by grief. Each of them feels guilty about Zach’s death, but they lack the ability to talk to one another about their feelings. Instead, Zach’s presence haunts them. They focus on the moment of his death so much that they struggle to remember anything other than the way he died. Zach’s unexpected death comes to define him, and the weight of their guilt creates distance between the family members. The haunting memory of Zach and his death drives them apart, rather than bringing them together to remember his positive impact on their lives.

After the end of the noble silence, Masha gathers everyone in the basement meditation chamber and reveals to them that they’ll all take part in a guided meditation ceremony, which will use hallucinogenic drugs to help them come to terms with their problems. She also reveals that she’s been secretly administering these drugs to her guests ever since they arrived. This revelation shows the hollowness at the heart of Tranquillum House. Though Masha promises change and transformation, all she offers are uninformed, unethical, and unscientific solutions. Heather takes apart Masha’s defenses, revealing the hidden truth at the heart of Masha’s promises: Masha has no real solution and no real expertise. Everything at Tranquillum House is just illusion and deception, the promise of change and healing without any substance.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text