logo

54 pages 1 hour read

Charles Dickens

Pickwick Papers

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 1836

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Themes

The Inequity of the Justice System

Before becoming a novelist, Dickens was a legal clerk and court reporter, and as a child he visited his father in debtors’ prison. His firsthand experience with England’s courts and prisons of that era informs many of his novels, particularly Bleak House, and the inequity of the justice system is a central focus throughout The Pickwick Papers, especially during the court proceedings of Bardell v. Pickwick and Pickwick’s experience in prison. The novel depicts Bardell v. Pickwick as an entirely farcical trial in which no evidence except a misunderstanding shows Pickwick’s guilt. In Chapter 34, Mrs. Bardell’s lawyers present evidence against Pickwick that they’ve completely contrived and then try to convince the jury that Pickwick’s simple messages to Bardell were “covert, sly, underhanded communications” (605) by interpreting ordinary objects as codewords. The whole trial is based on Bardell’s misinterpretation of Pickwick’s intentions, not unlike the other sham trial the Pickwickians face at Nupkins’ house. Pickwick is again assumed to have intentions he doesn’t when Miss Witherfield believes that Pickwick wants to duel Mr. Magnus.

The arrests of Sam and the other Pickwickians are similarly based on misunderstandings during the public procession made of Pickwick’s arrest, and no actual evidence is ever brought against Pickwick when Nupkins considers his guilt. A few times, characters even take justice into their own hands: Dr. Slammer by proposes a duel, while Sam fakes a crime with the good intention to get into prison with Pickwick. Overall, the novel presents the legal system as largely ineffectual and superfluous.

Pickwick’s experience in prison is an extension of his experience in court because it shows how the foundation of the entire justice system allows for individuals to be treated differently based on class and position. After seeing the “poor side” of the prison, Pickwick can no longer stand to witness the awful scenes around him and remarks, “I have seen enough [...] My head aches with these scenes, and my heart too. Henceforth I will be a prisoner in my own room” (818). In addition, the text includes several pitiable figures whom the courts have wronged and placed in the Fleet Street Prison, such as Sam’s cobbler roommate and the landlord of Pickwick’s room, whom Pickwick believes has essentially “been slowly murdered by the law” (796). Dickens, an advocate for prison and legal reform, uses these elements of The Pickwick Papers to highlight the inequity and inefficacy those caught up in the British justice system are bound to face, particularly those who have less means than characters like the wealthy Pickwick.

Friendship and Loyalty

The influence of friendship and loyalty on characters’ relationships with one another is central throughout The Pickwick Papers, in which the story concerns the travels of a group of friends. The novel focuses on Pickwick and his three closest friends within the Pickwick Club as well as the friends they make along the way. Pickwick and his entourage make friends quickly and easily, as evident in how many people they invite to dine or stay with them during their journeys, such as Jingle, Dowler, and Magnus. However, the Pickwickians’ budding relationships with Wardle and the Dingley Dell company are often at the forefront, and they consider the Pickwickians more like family than friends by the end of the novel, when the Pickwickians promise to make a yearly pilgrimage to Manor Farm.

In addition, the Pickwickians share deep bonds with one another, which are evident early on in The Pickwick Papers. When Winkle is challenged to a duel and asks Snodgrass to be his second, thinking he’ll betray the plan and tell Pickwick about the duel to stop it, Winkle is surprised when Snodgrass tells him, “In the cause of friendship [...] I would brave all Dangers” (45), and agrees to everything Winkle asks of him. In the following chapter, Pickwick’s friends must physically restrain him so that he doesn’t attack those who have slandered them, an act that he often repeats throughout the novel out of his deep concern for the honor of his friends.

Loyalty is another a central focus of The Pickwick Papers, not only between friends but also between employees and employers. Even Job Trotter is incredibly loyal to the scoundrel Jingle, accompanying him into prison and leaving England with him even though he knows of Jingle’s devious ways. The novel’s primary example of loyalty, however, is Sam’s loyalty to Pickwick. Just as Pickwick does for his friends, Sam defends Pickwick’s honor whenever it’s questioned and calls him “a reg’lar thoroughbred angel” (815). When Pickwick tells Sam to find work elsewhere while he’s in prison and says he’ll continue to pay Sam’s wages, Sam responds, “This here sort o’ thing won’t do at all” (746) and gets his father to arrest him for his debt so that he can be forced to stay with Pickwick until he leaves prison. Even when Pickwick tells Sam he’s done with adventuring and no longer needs a valet and suggests that Sam wed Mary, Sam refuses to leave Pickwick and only marries once Pickwick forces Mary’s hand. Additionally, the text implies that Sam stays nearby Pickwick even after this: “[T]wo sturdy little boys [have] been repeatedly seen at the gate of the back garden” of Pickwick’s house (1013). Overall, The Pickwick Papers touts loyalty and friendship as some of the most desirable attributes.

The Enlightening Effects of Travel

The primary goal of the Pickwick Club is to travel and observe cultures far from home. Although this goal is fairly ironic given that the Pickwickians never travel beyond a few counties from London and mostly engage with people similar to themselves, they nonetheless learn from their experiences while traveling. Domestic travel gained popularity in England at the end of the 18th century, and thus the old-fashioned Pickwickian travels to towns in Kent and to destinations like Bath were somewhat common at the time. Despite their relative nearness, the places the Pickwickians travel are typically country settings very different from their residences in the bustling city of London. Although the people they meet along their journeys, such as Wardle and the Dowlers, run in similar social circles as the Pickwickians, their acquaintance nevertheless expands, and they form new friendships and relationships the more they travel through England, creating an increasingly tangled web of connections as they go.

One of the most notable elements of the Pickwickians’ travels is that they face new and novel predicaments wherever they go. After one of their misadventures, Pickwick even exclaims, “Is it not a wonderful circumstance [...] that we seem destined to enter no man’s house without involving him in some degree of trouble?” (315). While not all of the trouble the Pickwickians encounter leads to a learning experience, much of it does or at least requires the travelers to question their morals or outlook on the world. For example, when the Pickwickians visit Eatanswill and are caught in the midst of political turmoil between the Blues and the Buffs, they must consider the effects of the town’s extreme partisanship and can see from an outsider’s perspective how it hinders progress in Eatanswill.

Other predicaments, such as Pickwick’s being caught while drunk on a stranger’s property or being assumed to have started a duel and thus being brought to Nupkins’ home for judgment are characteristic of both the comedic nature of The Pickwick Papers and the Pickwickians’ penchant for being thrown into circumstantial turmoil during their travels. Although these experiences as a whole depict the hilarity and chaos of the group’s travels, the characters, particularly Pickwick, take what they learn back with them to London and consider it in making future decisions. Much like the antique stone Pickwick brings back from his travels, his journeys make him more enlightened and empathetic. Although he chased Jingle throughout England and wanted to bring him to justice, Pickwick’s experience in diverse settings and with different people lead him to see Jingle in a new light at Fleet Street Prison. As is the goal of the Pickwick Club, its members become more enlightened and experience more of the world as they travel.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text