55 pages • 1 hour read
Mona AwadA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Awad emphasizes the effect of childhood experiences and mother-daughter relationships on adult self-esteem and priorities throughout the novel. One of the factors that most strongly affects Mira’s self-esteem is her relationship with her mother. Noelle’s comments on her own appearance affect her daughter’s self-esteem deeply. Whereas Mira sees Noelle as extremely beautiful, her mother makes continual self-deprecating comments, and when Noelle compliments Mira, these comments focus on the comparison between them. For example, when they are discussing their different complexions due to Mira’s Egyptian father, Noelle says: “Lucky, do you hear me? She wished she had your skin and your hair, absolutely. Definitely. And then she petted you like a dog. […] And you knew then that she was lying. She didn’t wish that. Not at all” (6). Awad represents the damage of such statements as twofold. First, the comparisons highlight the difference between mother and daughter. Given how beautiful Mira believes her mother to be, this sense of difference or contrast makes her feel ugly, even if her mother is being sincere. Second, Noelle’s negative attitude toward her own appearance—which Mira considers a paragon of beauty—creates the idea that beauty is unattainable. Through this, Awad shows that even innocuous statements can impact a child’s self-image.
Awad also focuses on other formative childhood experiences like games. Mira remembers several childhood games focusing on beauty. One is called “Honestly,” in which one girl closes her eyes and the others raise their hands if they think she is beautiful. The number of hands is anonymously revealed after. While the other girls laugh and worry aloud that no one will think they are beautiful, they always receive votes. Mira is the only girl who receives no votes in the game. Like many of the discussions surrounding beauty in the novel, this scene implies that Mira is singled out because she isn’t white. As such, the game shows how white beauty standards are upheld and maintained within social circles, even among children.
Seth’s grooming represents how children are targeted by the beauty industry and, with his resemblance to Tom Cruise, how strongly media can affect young people. He uses a mirror to groom Mira into one of Rouge’s “vessels,” calling her a “seedling” throughout the novel. As such, Awad creates a metaphor for the negative consequences of the media and beauty industry on children. His celebrity doppelganger shows how young people might trust celebrities and media figures who then exploit that trust. While his actions are fantastical, they reflect the real danger that can be lurking in things like advertising campaigns or influencer videos designed to sell products, which are often targeted toward children and young adults.
While Seth targets Mira as a child specifically, his actions and Rouge’s mission are a metaphor for the negative effects of the beauty industry more broadly. While not mystical, Seth has his counterpart in Marva, an influencer whom Mira reveres and follows dogmatically. Marva’s presence throughout the novel highlights how Mira’s induction into the world of beauty has persisted into adulthood, with a new set of impossible standards to adhere to. This is satirized through Marva’s interminable skincare journeys, which all seem to cause or contradict each other—using retinol on an anti-aging journey, for example, irritates the skin and sparks an anti-inflammatory journey. Mira trusts Marva, and the novel immediately establishes the high costs of attaining beauty through her faith. While she forgets to pack a dress for her mother’s funeral, she packs seven bags of skincare products, hundreds or thousands of dollars’ worth of products. Likewise, Noelle has gone into debt to pay for Rouge’s treatments. These costs extend to psychological tolls—later, Mira reflects that “mental reshuffling” is a “small price to pay for this level of collagen regeneration” (201). This statement suggests that cognitive function is a reasonable sacrifice for beautiful skin. Similarly, Mira’s obsession with acids suggests the pain involved in beauty is a reasonable cost.
Awad also highlights the insidious and omnipresent nature of the beauty industry via social media and technology. Even before she encounters Rouge, Mira is obsessed with watching skincare videos on social media, to the detriment of her other priorities. When she sees the initial ad for Rouge—in which Awad mimics typical beauty industry marketing language—the scene becomes uncanny: “‘Where does the secret lie?’ It’s the woman in red talking again. A voice-over that sounds not like it’s coming from my phone’s speaker, but whispering right in my ear” (30). While Mira first encounters Rouge through technology, the auditory imagery here blends the ad with reality, leaving them indistinguishable. As such, this scene bridges the gap between beauty industry messaging and the horrors of Rouge represented throughout the novel. This reflects the negative aspects of beauty messaging becoming exponentially more prevalent in daily life.
The novel also critiques the beauty industry’s preference for whiteness and the way it upholds systemic racism. Awad moves from realistic representations of racism to supernatural instances of horrifying racism as Mira moves deeper into the world of Rouge. Racism is present in early interactions with Noelle and Mira’s childhood friends, who characterize her as “other” or “exotic” due to her Egyptian heritage. One of the effects of Rouge’s treatments is whitening: Mira observes that a woman who has just had a treatment is “[p]aler than last time. As if the color had been leached out of her skin a little. She had a whiteness. A Brightness, call it a Brightness” (201). Awad thus highlights an assumption that paleness is associated with beauty. The fact that characters who work at Rouge repeatedly tell customers to call this effect “brightness” rather than “whiteness” suggests that they are aware of and use euphemisms to disguise their inherent racism.
The beauty nature’s exploitative nature is clearest in the novel’s climax after Mira’s third treatment. While ostensibly perfected, she and the other women have no memories, and even their beauty seems to be a ruse or a magic glamour—Lake’s face becomes more shadowy as Mira looks at her, and she secretly thinks she looks dead. This reflects how the beauty industry’s promises are false or, in some cases, harmful, and it culminates in the scene when Lake’s jellyfish is eaten alive by Rouge’s diners. In the gory scene, it becomes clear that Rouge steals souls and devours them to benefit a select few, a metaphor for the way the beauty industry exploits people to generate profits. Awad asserts that there is no winning within the system, and the only way to escape this cycle is through solidarity and resistance. Noelle and the other jellyfish help Mira swim to freedom, breaking the spell and drowning the evil-doers. Similarly, Sylvia helps Mira recover and rebuild her life, and the novel ends with Mira leading an addled Hud back to shore. The dark fairy tale ends with a glimmer of hope as its characters move into a future without Rouge.
One of the main suspenseful elements in the novel is the mystery surrounding Noelle’s character and intentions. The structure—incorporating flashbacks and memories—features the gradual reveal of details about Noelle’s life and personality, her interactions with Mira, and the period immediately preceding her death. Awad, therefore, creates intrigue about what Noelle became embroiled in at Rouge and how she felt about her daughter. Alongside other magical elements, Noelle influences her daughter from beyond the grave, as if remembering her is an act of raising the dead. The autonomous red shoes—and later, the red jellyfish—are Noelle’s posthumous attempts to protect her daughter. Mira “remember[s] that it took a while to get down here to the Treatment Room. Because of my red shoes. Again, I had to take them off […] It was so silly. I really shouldn’t wear them to the house anymore” (202). While Mira brushes the experience off at the time, it later becomes clear that preventing her from walking down the stairs is a protective gesture. While Mira’s memories reveal the negative aspects of Noelle’s character, they also reflect Noelle’s love for her daughter and attempts to protect her.
The Rouge treatments focus on repressed memories. When Mira still thinks she is getting a standard facial, she talks about extractions, referring to blackheads and other skin impurities. The person performing the treatment refers to the connection between bad memory and bad skin, which establishes that the treatment removes memory. For Mira, these memories center on Seth and her childhood trauma, which she repressed. After Mira poisons her mother, Grand-Maman advises Mira to bury her memories and keep them locked away to cope. However, this proves to be bad advice, leaving Mira in an unhealed state with both herself and her mother. Unearthing these painful memories is key to Mira’s character arc, even though she initially loses herself entirely—what is being extracted is not just memory but her soul, and after receiving several treatments, she no longer looks like herself. Awad therefore highlights the importance of memory to one’s sense of self, and taking them away from Mira leaves her vulnerable to further exploitation.
At the same time, examining these repressed memories becomes the key to Mira’s escape. While she is foggy after her third treatment—when she sees her most traumatic memory—she also sees glimmers of the truth, thinking Lake looks dead and feeling uneasy about what’s happening. Confronting her past is the first step in breaking the spell, and it allows her and her mother’s jellyfish to meld together and aid her escape. On the beach afterward, Noelle’s jellyfish turns into a human for one last moment, during which Mira and her mother reminisce together and reconcile. When Mira awakes, her memories are largely restored, and she is on her way to healing. Awad asserts that repressed memories will allow harm and trauma to negatively affect the present, and the path forward lies in confronting these painful memories.
By Mona Awad