51 pages • 1 hour read
Kate DiCamilloA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
The Chronicles of Sorrowing is the book of prophecy at the center of the conflict in The Beatryce Prophecy, so named because the majority of the prophecies it contains are sorrowful ones of death and destruction. Within the frame of the story, the book embodies the theme Destiny Is a Choice, and the decisions the characters make about the prophecies in the chronicle’s pages represent how nothing is certain. The prophecies in the book are vague, which means they can be easily manipulated and made to mean whatever someone wishes them to mean. The counselor does this in his plan to exact revenge on Beatryce’s family, but blatantly manipulating vagueness is not the only way the prophecies may be used. Beatryce and her group also manipulate prophecies by ignoring them, thus taking away their power. By choosing not to validate the Chronicles of Sorrowing, the characters force society to acknowledge that prophecies are meaningless and that people can make their own choices.
Within the story and as a representation of real life, the Chronicles of Sorrowing represent the darkness in the world and how people can bring light. Much like sensationalist news media, the Chronicles of Sorrowing focus heavily on bad outcomes and negative possibilities. By doing so, the prophecies send the message that the past, present, and future have been and will be dominated by death, war, and violence. If not questioned, this becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy in which people seek negative events as the cause of the prophecies and learn not to trust in positive outcomes because there is always another prophecy waiting to make things worse again. Edik’s insistence on making the letters in the Chronicles of Sorrowing colorful represents how a person can fight back against negativity. Edik acts the way he wants the world to be, and though progress is slow, his positivity eventually wins out as the Chronicles of Sorrowing are rendered obsolete.
The mermaid appears in multiple forms throughout the novel, most prominently as the hairbrush belonging to Edik’s mother and in Beatryce’s story at the end of the book. In all her iterations, the mermaid calls to Destiny Is a Choice and Coping with Trauma, and Beatryce’s and Edik’s relationships to the mermaid inform both their characters and the novel as a whole. Beatryce uses the mermaid as a coping mechanism during times of darkness. From the time Edik tells her about the hairbrush, Beatryce wonders about the mermaid’s story. Before leaving the monastery, she promises Edik she’ll write the mermaid’s story, and her ability to do so at different points shows where she is along her character arc and her ability to face her past. When taking the soldier’s confession, the mermaid’s story becomes a lifeline for Beatryce to focus on when she can’t deal with what the soldier did and how his actions destroyed her family. Beatryce is only able to write the first line of the story at this point, showing how she gets stuck in the trauma of her past. Later in the dungeon, Beatryce is able to compose the entire story and tell it to the king, showing that she has grown and also that she is not afraid to tell her story since the mermaid’s tale is so similar.
To Edik, the mermaid begins as a cautionary tale. He remembers the brush at a moment when he is trying to find a way to protect Beatryce. The brush makes him realize that Beatryce is not safe as a girl who can read, which prompts him to disguise her as a boy. Here, the mermaid is in direct opposition to Being True to Oneself because it represents the limitations put on women in the novel’s world and how Beatryce must hide her true self to stay safe. At the end of the book, the mermaid aligns with this theme as Edik dedicates his days to writing stories for the people, the mermaid’s tale being the first. In this way, the mermaid’s story also becomes a symbol of change because it will be one of the first stories used to teach people to read and usher in a new age of information for all.
The sword that Jack takes from the soldier in Chapter 23 has several meanings throughout the novel. For Jack, it represents Coping with Trauma and Being True to Oneself, as it plays a key role in his transformation. When Jack first takes up the sword, he is glad to have it because he feels it gives him power and that if he were to encounter the robber again, he would be prepared this time. As the story progresses and Jack comes to realize that the people in his present mean just as much to him as his parents, he understands that the sword is not a symbol of strength but of weakness. Using the sword to harm someone for revenge won’t change the past and will only do Jack more emotional harm. Rather, using it to protect Beatryce, as he does in the final chapters, fills him with a sense of love and pride because he is being his true caring self.
The sword also represents Coping with Trauma for Beatryce. From the moment she learns of its existence, the sword becomes a trigger for her. The soldier’s description of what he did with the sword calls to the memories Beatryce has buried. She knows the sword was used against her, but she can’t yet deal with this, instead falling into a semiconscious state where her mind desperately works to protect her from the truth. She refuses to touch the sword once they take it from the soldier because she knows what it did and knows that she can’t bear to feel the energy on it. By contrast, Jack feels comforted by the sword’s destructive energy at first. When he ultimately decides not to kill the robber, however, the sword loses its importance to him. The weapon is not mentioned again after this point, showing that it no longer has a hold over either Jack or Beatryce.
By Kate DiCamillo