logo

19 pages 38 minutes read

Robert W. Service

The Cremation of Sam McGee

Fiction | Poem | Adult | Published in 1907

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Symbols & Motifs

The Ghost of Sam McGee

It could be argued that this is a Halloween poem set during Christmastime. The poem’s closing image of the dead prospector Sam McGee reclining in the roaring furnace fire symbolizes a wonderful kind of narrative open-endedness, a rollicking conclusion in which nothing is concluded. Service taps into the popular tradition of ballads, story-songs set to accessible and ear-friendly rhythms and rhymes designed to delight and engage. The climactic moment when Cap sees Sam McGee, smiling, sitting “cool and calm” (Line 57) in the heart of the raging furnace fire, is never resolved.

The “queerest” (Line 66) moment of Cap seeing Sam is offered without irony and without explanation. Many possibilities exist for the reader to interpret Sam’s presence: Perhaps Sam thawed like some frozen slab of venison, in a manic skewering of the Christian Easter belief in resurrection; maybe Cap is seeing the ghost of Sam McGee, a manifestation of a paranormal dimension now finally at peace, warm at last; the moment could be a Freudian projection of an honest Cap who is happy that his friend is at last out of the arctic cold but certain now of his own fast-approaching demise; or Cap could be having a simple hallucination, a wish projection, compelled by his own susceptibility to the extreme weather. Cap is a consummate storyteller and purposely leaves the climax open.

The Huskies

Much as in the naturalist fiction of Jack London, a contemporary writer whose adventure tales of the Yukon enthralled Robert W. Service, animals know more than people. As the poem opens, Cap and Sam are “mushing” (Line 11), a transportation method that uses dogs to pull a sled—in this poem, the dogs pulling Cap’s sled are huskies. The huskies are mentioned three times in the poem—and each time they are more in tune with the conditions in the Yukon than they are with the unfolding drama of the cremation of Sam McGee. The huskies that pull Cap’s sled understand only survival.

As the narrative unfolds and Cap makes increasingly clear his intention to fulfill his foolish promise, the huskies symbolize the sublime indifference of nature itself. Throughout the ordeal of Sam McGee’s death and then the arduous journey across miles of open tundra to cremate a body, the dogs stay indifferent to such emotional and psychological urgencies, unavailable to the implications of mortality or to the test of character integrity implied by the speaker’s promise and his determination to keep his word. For the huskies, moving steadily, unerringly across the wilderness waste is just and only that. The huskies eat when they are hungry, burrow deep into the snow drifts to maintain body heat, howl when they feel the need, and pull the sled bearing the corpse without emotion, without reaction, indifferent to the speaker’s journey, as noble as it is foolhardy. Like the stars in the night sky, like the midnight sun, like the forever-whorling snow, the huskies care little about the petty tragicomedies of humanity.

The Alice May

Good fortune seems to be hard to find in the ballad of Sam McGee. The wreck of the Alice May symbolizes the unexpected moments of serendipity, moments when an otherwise indifferent universe appears to relent sufficiently to let some good fortune happen. The very nature of the happenstance is suggested by the ship’s name—Alice may or may not. The unsung hero of the ballad of Sam McGee turns out to be sheer luck: the wrecked hull of the Alice May that Cap happens upon after days of futilely searching the Arctic wastes for a site dry enough, with wood enough, to cremate the corpse he is lugging around.

The ship, apparently grounded then abandoned in the treacherous ice of Lake Lebarge, offers up its very planks and its precious cache of coal to help make good the speaker’s reckless promise. As Sam burns, so does the ship. If the speaker never stumbled upon the wrecked, derelict ship, then the tragedy of Sam McGee might have included Cap himself, doomed to wander forever like some nightmarish version of notorious ghost ship the Flying Dutchman, or the Mariner from Samuel Taylor Coleridge’s “The Rime of the Ancient Mariner” (1798). The happy ending, such as it is, is made possible by the unexpected and entirely unearned intrusion of happenstance, symbolized by the wreck of the Alice May.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text