logo

42 pages 1 hour read

James Tiptree Jr.

The Girl Who Was Plugged In

Fiction | Novella | Adult | Published in 1973

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Literary Devices

Narrative Voice

From the first lines of the story, we’re introduced to a strong and distinctive narrative voice. Throughout, this voice intervenes directly in the narrative to comment on the action, raise questions, and give asides that describe aspects of the future world. The voice is full of personality, with unusual diction and a punchy, sardonic style.

This voice is consciously aware of itself as telling a story from some point in the future to an audience of people in our present (its past). This comes across forcefully in the opening lines with the address to an implied audience of “zombies” and “dead daddies”—a male audience, obsessed with its wealth and status, and one located in the past. The narrator seems keen to educate or shock this audience in some way. She wants Burke’s story to disrupt their world view. In the conclusion, there’s an ironic concession to the limitations of this disruption, as the narrator reassures her audience there’s plenty of opportunity for “capital appreciation” (78) in the future.

At key points, the narrator steps back and lets the action unfold more directly, but her presence is never too far away. When she steps in with an ironic question or comment it disrupts the immediacy and realism of the story, reminding us we’re hearing or reading a story. Her interventions are meta-fictional devices, drawing attention to the process of storytelling. There’s an interesting thematic connection here with the way identification and immersion work in the narrative itself. As readers, we’re variously held back and drawn into the story, encouraged to identify with Burke, but then also distanced from her by the narrator’s descriptions and comments. Like Burke, we cannot lose ourselves completely in another life and story. Behind the illusion of fiction is the complex system of language and signification.

Another analogy that helps explain Tiptree’s narrative strategy is with the world of cultural production described in the story. The mainstream show, like the one Delphi is part of, are described as a kind of empty escapism and wish-fulfilment. Delphi is a hit because people “IDENTIFY” (61); they’re drawn into her and forget themselves in the process. In contrast, Paul’s underground productions work through: “bizarre techniques and unsettling distortions, pregnant with social protest” (65). These techniques have the opposite effect of identification—they distance and alienate the viewer, forcing them to remain critically alert. Arguably, Tiptree is attempting something similar in this story. Using her own kinds of unsettling distortions and interruptions, she keeps the reader alert and self-aware, focused on the social implications of her narrative, rather than drawing us into an escapist illusion, where we simply and passively identify.

Foreshadowing and Suspense

The narrator sometimes holds us in suspense about how the action will proceed, and at other times hints at or reveals how the story will end in advance.

For instance, at the beginning of the story, the allusion to fatal encounters between mortals and gods already strongly suggests a tragic ending for P. Burke. The narrator emphasises this again at a key turning point in the story, when Burke falls for Paul and begins striving to become Delphi: she “should have noticed those stories about mortals who end up as grasshoppers” (66).

There are also the allusions to GTX’s more sinister actions, which serve as another kind of foreshadowing of P. Burke’s fate. For example, the section omitted from Mr. Cantle’s speech to P. Burke (which would have been about disobedience and its costs, the death of Rima, that “certain Beautiful Person who didn’t wake up” (53), reveals a part of the story which is left deliberately and ominously undisclosed as a silent warning. This tension between what’s concealed and revealed runs throughout the story. It’s another device the narrator uses to disrupt realism and easy immersion and encourage a more distanced and critical engagement.

At some key moments, Tiptree purposefully lead us into a moment of narrative uncertainty. For example, when Burke attempts suicide, we’re only told about “a few furtive hand gestures” (44). It’s only later, after a digression on GTX, and when we see her collapse, and finally when an official in hospital tells her public suicide is a felony, that it becomes clear. Before that clarification, we’re left guessing at events. Similarly, Tiptree lets us believe with Burke, for a moment, that Paul has grasped the truth that she’s a Remote and still loves her.

Circular Structure

By the end of the novella, things have neatly come full circle in several ways. After the narrative expands away from P. Burke and her capsule to the jet-setting life of Delphi, it returns to her in her capsule in the final tragic scenes. The two separate but co-dependent worlds of P. Burke and Delphi are brought crashing together in a way that destroys them both. As the narrative reaches it finale, the sense of a return to origins is overtly stressed: “Behind that door is the very suite where she was born” (75).

The circularity works on the level of temporality and framing structure as well. The “sharp faced lad” ends up back in our timeline, America 1971, and the implication is his arrival will help our world along its journey to the future we’ve just been shown. In terms of the story’s framing structure, the narrator ends precisely where she began, with an address to her audience, and the very same words: “Believe it, zombie” (78). We’ve come full circle, to the question of capital growth and this audience of men. These levels of circularity imply continuity. Burke remains unknown, Delphi carries on with another remote, the social order keeps on rolling, people keep investing, admiring their gods, and buying products. But for all this, we’ve been shown something different, something that doesn’t break the continuity of this social order, but at least puts a question to it.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text