40 pages • 1 hour read
Andrzej SapkowskiA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Nenneke awakens Geralt and sends away the woman who had sex with him, Iola. Geralt tries to speak with her, but Nenneke tells him Iola has taken a vow of silence.
Geralt is resting and healing at Melitele’s temple in Ellander. Nenneke examines and redresses his wounds, chastising him for allowing a striga to hurt him so badly.
The cult of Melitele is a contemporary instance of various pre-human religions that worshipped goddesses of harvest and fertility. Though many other religions have waned, the cult of Melitele remains strong.
Nenneke finds Geralt walking. The two argue about whether a trance will help Geralt, who insists that he is immune. Nenneke believes it can’t hurt.
Geralt sees birds circling around the mutilated corpses of two travelers. He concludes that a few days prior, the pair had been traveling home from the direction of a nearby forest when something attacked them. However, other features of the scene puzzle him, and he decides to investigate.
In the forest, Geralt finds a tower. While descending a slope to the tower wall, he senses someone watching him. He spots a girl with enormous, black eyes following their movements, but when he greets her, she disappears into the forest at an enormous speed.
No one answers at the tower gate, so Geralt and Roach enter the courtyard. Suddenly, a humanoid monster charges them; however, the creature stops upon seeing Geralt’s sword. He roars and threatens Geralt, ordering him to leave, but when Geralt doesn’t flee, his tone becomes cheeky and quizzical. He tries to direct Geralt back to the highway, but when Geralt requests some water as a guest, the monster relents and invites him in.
The tower is a magical mansion that responds to the commands and desires of the monster, Nivellen, even making a full meal appear before their eyes. The magical nature of the mansion came with Nivellen’s change of appearance 12 years before; however, he declines to tell Geralt how he came to look as he does.
Nivellen points Geralt in the direction of an old portrait to show him what he used to look like. When Geralt can easily see the faraway portrait, even though it is beyond human sight, Geralt admits that he’s a witcher. Nivellen knows that witchers kill monsters and lays out a hypothetical battle between them. Nivellen believes he is likely to win.
Geralt does not believe Nivellen is a monster since he can touch silver. Nivellen dismisses this because of his appearance, but Geralt argues that that his appearance might be a spell that can be undone. However, Nivellen doesn’t want it undone.
Nivellen came from a family of thieves and con artists. His father used to watch the highway from the tower and rob anyone who came by. After his father was killed, Nivellen took over the gang, but he was so young and soft that he quickly lost control of the others, who ran wild. After robbing a temple, they made Nivellen rape a priestess, who cursed Nivellen before killing herself. A few days later, he awoke looking as he does now; he scared off most of the servants and, in a blind rage, murdered the rest.
Several months later, Nivellen saw a man picking roses for his daughter from the tower’s rosebushes. Nivellen demanded the man’s daughter or his life, but the girl was only eight, so Nivellen sent the man away with gold. Word spread. Local families sent their daughters to live with Nivellen for a time in exchange for small fortunes.
Geralt has by now deduced that Nivellen now lives with the girl Geralt saw in the forest—she must be why other young women have been going home empty-handed. Geralt offers to help Nivellen with his appearance or the girl, but Nivellen declines.
Nivellen accidentally reveals that his current companion’s name is Vereena. They love each other. Geralt is surprised—he thinks Vereena is a rusalka, an entity malicious toward humans, and that Nivellen is afraid Vereena will leave him if he reverts to his human form. Nivellen knows that Geralt is tracking the merchants, but Nivellen is unaware that they were murdered.
That night in the forest, Geralt hears the screams of a tortured woman. The next day, he investigates to find warm ashes and charred bones. Later, when a “devil’s ring” of mushrooms spooks Roach, Geralt recalls Nivellen’s statement that animals like him, which leads to a revelation about Vereena.
When Geralt returns to the tower, Vereena is singing through her closed mouth in a language he doesn’t recognize. Geralt accuses Vereena of turning Nivellen into a true monster so that they can rule the forest together. He has realized that she is a bruxa—a kind of vampire—rather than a rusalka. Vereena attacks. The two battle for some time, until Nivellen impales her, but she pulls herself along the pole toward Nivellen. Before she kills Nivellen, Geralt decapitates her. Nivellen returns to his human form.
Nenneke serves as a counterpoint to Geralt; she is not quite a foil, as they are alike in many ways, but she is the only character who consistently challenges him out of respect, unlike other characters, who mostly challenge him out of animosity. Both are powerful and confident, bordering on arrogant, and both are stubborn, but their understanding of the world differs: Geralt has a pragmatic, earthly perspective, while Nenneke roots her understanding in her spiritualism. This sometimes puts them at odds with one another.
“A Grain of Truth” most overtly wrestles with the “man or monster” dichotomy, featuring a literal man/monster hybrid creature. Like Geralt, Nivellen is often ambivalent regarding his monstrousness, which can sometimes be an advantage—he scares people off, and he has steady chain of willing concubines. His hybridity interrogates what it means be a monster: Nivellen believes he is one because of his heinous violent crimes and his appearance, whereas Geralt denies his monstrosity, which is the result of a reversible curse. Geralt points out that when Nivellen committed these acts, he was a child raised in a household of thieves and forced into the actions that brought the curse upon him. Nivellen’s guilt doesn’t sway Geralt to forgive or condemn him—Geralt is only focused on the evil magic at play.
“Grain” is an obvious nod to the familiar fairy tale “Beauty and the Beast”—Nivellen is a cursed beast-man who lives in a magical mansion that serves him. However, in “Grain,” there are two version of the beauty: village girls who live with Nivellen for money, and Vereena, the nefarious vampire-like creature who wants to rid Nivellen of his humanity.
“Grain” tells us more about the misunderstood profession of witcher. We get a fuller sense of people’s animosity toward witchers that wasn’t quite in place in the first long chapter. There, we could write off the townspeople’s dislike because Geralt is Rivian. Nivellen, though, makes an uneasy jest about hunting witchers, raising the question about the necessity of witchers.
By Andrzej Sapkowski