93 pages • 3 hours read
Amor TowlesA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
In Manhattan, Duchess has arrived at the Sunshine Hotel, the less than reputable establishment where Duchess lived with his father for four years before his incarceration at Salina. Two years have passed since they have seen one another, but when Duchess knocks on the door of room 42, he is surprised when a stranger answers the door. The old man doesn’t know Duchess’s father or where he has gone, but he presents Duchess with a box that his father left behind in the room. It is one of six boxes his father possessed, each containing the personal effects of a different Shakespearean lead his father portrayed. This box is labeled O for Othello, and it houses a dagger, an earring, stage makeup, and a false goatee. These boxes were precious to his father, especially this box from Othello, so Duchess knows if it has been left behind, it can only mean his father departed with haste.
The man currently inhabiting the room has only been living there since Monday, and Duchess suspects his father vacated the room after a call from Salina alerted to him to his son’s escape. As he is leaving, Duchess stops by room 49, one that he knows well, lingering for a moment in the open door before going to find Woolly in the lobby. After securing two rooms, Duchess asks the clerk if he knows where Harrison Hewett might have gone. The clerk doesn’t know but suggests Duchess check with another former resident, Fitzy FitzWilliams, a name Duchess also knows well. Fitzy had lived right across from Duchess and his father at the Sunshine Hotel. Fitzy had settled at the establishment after social plummet from the peak of celebrity and success as the premiere Santa in New York, exclusively catering to the wealthy elite, to the status of a communist sympathizing pariah. Duchess knows that FitzWilliams will likely know exactly where his father is.
When their boxcar reaches New York City, Ulysses acts as a guide to the Watson boys, helping them carefully navigate their way to a camp Ulysses has frequented over his years riding the rails. Emmett has explained his plans to locate Duchess through his father’s talent agency and has arranged for Billy to remain with Ulysses while Emmett accomplishes this task. Emmett is impatient with Ulysses, who, with his experience and knowledge of the city and the camp they are going to, takes the lead. Ulysses has no patience for Emmett’s questioning, and, when Billy stops to admire the view and Emmett and Ulysses find that he is momentarily out of their sight, Ulysses becomes frustrated. Ulysses stresses to Billy the importance of always remaining within touching distance of Emmett or himself. Billy has been drawn in by the sight of the Empire State Building and continues to marvel at the sights of the city around them as they make their way to the camp. Ulysses sneaks them into a building through which the train cars pass, using the boxcars as cover until they emerge at an abandoned section of track cordoned off by fencing.
Passing through a hole in the fence, they arrive at an encampment of makeshift shelters. Ulysses greets a man he calls Stew, who is surprised to find that Ulysses is in the company of others. Ulysses secures them an empty campsite and asks that Stew prepare a meal for them. When Emmett sees Ulysses reaching for his belongings as if to pay for their food, Emmett steps in and tries to cover the cost for all three. Taking it out, Emmett quickly realizes that the bill Mr. Parker placed in his pocket was not $5 but in fact $50. Ulysses scolds Emmett to put it away. Billy and Emmett dine on an expertly rendered chili, sitting by the fire and making small talk with two of the men living in the camp. When Billy is once again a bit too forthcoming about their plans to pick up their car and head out for California, and one of the men begins asking questions that set off warning bells for Ulysses, so Ulysses quickly intimidates the man and his companion into leaving the fireside, glowering at Emmett to impress upon him how unwise it is for Emmett to allow Billy to be so forthcoming about their circumstances.
Woolly is not happy to be in Manhattan, which he feels is “terribly permanent,” and “absotively [sic] filled with expectations” (264). The busy, densely populated city overwhelms and disorients him. Similarly, Woolly has always been bowled over by the volume of news and events he feels people in Manhattan are compelled to be appraised of, “things you were expected not only to be knowledgeable about, but on which you were expected to have an opinion that you could articulate at a moment’s notice” (265), a pressure he feels incapable of managing. Sitting in the lobby of the Sunshine Hotel waiting for Duchess, Woolly is pleased to find that the newspaper vendor who happens by is selling not just the papers of the day but newspapers from the past three days. Though the vendor’s price for all three papers is a nickel, Woolly happily gives him several bills that he finds in the pockets of Mr. Watson’s pants, telling the vendor that he can keep the change. In the evening, giving himself an additional dose of his medicine, Woolly pores over the papers and reads about the civil defense testing that had taken place in the city, transfixed by a published photo of Broadway from the evacuated test area, the streets empty and serene.
Duchess learns from Bernie at the Sunshine Hotel that his father and Fitzy are in the habit of commencing their heavy drinking each night around 8 pm at the Anchor bar, so Duchess sets himself up at the establishment, waiting. Duchess approaches Fitzy’s booth just as Fitzy is about to take his first drink, and Fitzy is shocked to see him. Fitzy observes how much Duchess has grown up, and Duchess cites the “hard labor” he has been subjected to as the cause, an intentional reference to his time in Salina. Duchess is direct with Fitzy about the fact that he is looking for his father, that they have “unfinished business” (270), and that Duchess suspects if anyone had any information about his father’s whereabouts it would be Fitzy. Fitzy claims that he has not seen Duchess’s father in weeks.
Duchess goes to the bar for a bottle of Fitzy’s chosen drink, presuming that if he plies Fitzy with what he wants most, Fitzy will be more likely to divulge his father’s whereabouts as the liquor takes effect. Duchess begins to allude to the circumstances of his incarceration, emphasizing the word “swore,” and “thieves,” to gauge Fitzy’s reactions. Finally, Fitzy utters his apology, “I’m so sorry, Duchess […] I’m sorry I put those things about you in that statement. Sorry that I signed it” (272). Fitzy begins making excuses about why he had acted that way. As Duchess goes quiet, he realizes that Fitzy is frightened of him. Using Fitzy’s fear to his advantage, Duchess issues a veiled threat, explaining that, having wronged him, if Fitzy were to tell him where his father had gone, he would consider them even. If not, Duchess informs him “I’ll have to use my imagination to think of some other way for the two of us to settle up” (273).
Sally is tearing up the road in her pickup named Betty and comes to an abrupt stop at the fence, where she finds her father in the field with two of his employees. Her father warns her if she continues to drive her truck that way it won’t last much longer, and he won’t help her repair it. Snapping back that she knows her truck and her father and knows what to expect from both, her father urges Sally to get on with whatever she has come to say. She produces the FOR SALE sign that had been posted at Emmett and Billy’s home and asks him why she found it in the trash. Her father explains that he has purchased the Watson home, and Sally confronts him, “The speed with which you bought the place […] it makes one wonder just how long you’ve been lying in wait to do so” (275), and further suggests her father might have helped Mr. Watson in all the time that the fam was failing. Her father dismisses his employees, waiting until they leave to address his daughter. He explains that, with Charlie Watson’s lack of skill and the financial struggles the family endured as a result, it was inevitable the farm would come up for sale, and it’s only natural that a rancher would try to expand his acreage.
Sally counters his argument by reminding her father he had nudged Emmett out of town and into the concession of the property to the bank, which is further evidence he was acting in his own interests. Seizing on the opportunity to address the issue of his daughter and Emmett, Mr. Ransom tells Sally that Emmett, like his mother, was never going to remain at the farm and that Emmett was eager to embrace the opportunity to make a life elsewhere. Her father likens people to “stayers,” and “goers,” and Sally challenges her father, asking which he thinks she is. Sally’s father tells her that he regrets having been so permissive with her after the passing of her mother, that she has become “willful,” and “unsuited to matrimony” (278), and she is incensed by the audacity that he exhibits in characterizing her in such a fashion. Enraged, she gets back into her truck and tears back to the house, screeching up to the front porch to find Sheriff Petersen waiting for her.
As Ulysses sits by the fire, Stew approaches him and asks if the Watson boys are leaving the following day. When Stew says that he will keep their bedding for them, he is surprised to hear Ulysses ask for his to be kept as well, knowing Ulysses to be a man who never spends more than one night in any given place. To Ulysses, Billy’s logic about friendship, which Billy had shared with him earlier, made the situation reasonable. If Ulysses remained another day and spent it in Billy’s company, their third day together would mark their transition from acquaintances to friends.
While Duchess settles in comfortably while visiting his former residence in the search for his father, Emmett’s comparative inexperience and Woolly’s discomfort with Manhattan are evidenced in their chapters. Though Emmett is concerned by his brother’s naïveté, Emmett himself is found lacking in certain skills that would have rendered their survival in Manhattan nearly impossible without Ulysses. Emmett’s plan to seek out Duchess’s father is sound, but the opportunity to pursue him without Billy would not have presented itself without Ulysses’s availability and willingness to volunteer for the task. While Woolly has seen too much of Manhattan and decides his place is not in it, Emmett has quickly seen enough after only a few hours in the city.
Unlike the circumstances in which he found himself when he was arrested in Manhattan and sent to Salina, Duchess returns to the city with a certain measure of power and leverage. Fitzy’s remark that Duchess is “all grown up” is not simply an observation of the change in Duchess’s physical stature. Duchess has also been afforded time to think about the people who have wronged him, and Fitzy is included on that list for his collusion with Duchess’s father. There is an element to Duchess’s carriage and presence that communicate to Fitzy that Duchess is someone to fear. Fitzy’s hesitancy and guardedness demonstrate a continued loyalty to Harrison, but that loyalty is not enough for him to protect his friend at the expense of his safety. Both Duchess’s narrative and Fitzy’s reactions communicate Duchess’s willingness to resort to violence to ascertain his father’s whereabouts, and Fitzy believes Duchess will make good on his threat to extract the information by whatever means necessary. Consistently afforded the opportunity to watch his father take advantage of others and exploit circumstances for his own personal gain, Duchess has embraced what he observed and honed similar skills during his time at Salina. When he appears at the Anchor, Duchess has the upper hand for the first time. Harrison Hewett’s disappearance from Manhattan after receiving notice of Duchess’s escape conveys not only Hewett’s acknowledgement that he had wronged his son but his presumption that his son’s destination would be New York to find his father.
For Sally, the tolerance that she has exhibited in enduring her father’s entitlement has been exhausted when he admonishes her for the strength of her personality and her willingness to voice her opinions and convictions. She is tired of assuming the responsibility of caretaker, particularly when she feels so taken advantage of. His purchase of the Watson property is a turning point in her perception of him. She had always thought him unappreciative, but she now begins to see him as exploitative, greedy, and opportunistic. When she prayed her father might find a wife who could take over the household duties, she was hoping it would provide a transition through which she would be relieved of the burden of caring for him. When he criticizes her so harshly despite all she has sacrificed to care for him since her mother’s death, her remaining threads of loyalty to him are severed, and she begins to mount her resolve to seek her own way and place in the world.
By Amor Towles
Action & Adventure
View Collection
Brothers & Sisters
View Collection
Family
View Collection
Fathers
View Collection
Friendship
View Collection
Hate & Anger
View Collection
Loyalty & Betrayal
View Collection
Mental Illness
View Collection
New York Times Best Sellers
View Collection
Popular Book Club Picks
View Collection
Revenge
View Collection
Sexual Harassment & Violence
View Collection
The Best of "Best Book" Lists
View Collection