44 pages • 1 hour read
Sarah Beth DurstA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
The next day, Kiela wakes to find forest spirits visiting her garden. They appear as ghostly bears and are meant to be solitary, except that many have gathered together. The bears lead Kiela into the forest to help a dying tree. Along the way, Kiela and Caz discuss stories about these bears leading people away and the people disappearing. Kiela buries her spells beneath the tree roots, and the tree is healed. Before they leave, Kiela is astonished to see a unicorn crossing their path. She takes it as a positive omen. When they return to the cottage, they see that the forest spirits have left them gifts.
The next day, Kiela processes her strange experience. She wants to tell Larran but can’t confess her illegal magical activities. Eadie comes by and pays Kiela for the tree remedy. Kiela decides to bring some jam to Larran and Bryn, but when she goes into town, she finds it deserted. She runs into Fenerer, who accosts her and accuses her of bringing trouble to the island. At Bryn’s bakery, Bryn tells her that an alarm has been sounded warning of an oncoming storm. On her way back, Kiela finds that the magical storm has grown too fierce for her to return home, and so she stops at Larran’s instead.
Kiela desperately knocks on Larran’s door and is pulled inside. He gives her a change of clothes and explains that the storm is caused by magic thrown out of balance. They watch the storm out the window and nearly kiss, but Larran sees someone out on the waves. He runs outside to help despite the danger. Kiela watches the rescue, terrified for his safety, until he and an unconscious woman return.
Kiela returns home and greets Caz, who was sick with worry. He leads her inside to reveal a mermaid waiting in the bathtub, along with her sick baby. The mermaid believes that Kiela can heal him the way she healed the trees. Kiela realizes that the baby is “storm sick,” having absorbed too much magical energy from the storm. She and Caz go into research mode and search their books for an answer. They find a cure for the illness and run around gathering ingredients. Kiela makes a paste and applies it to the baby’s body, curing him.
After the mermaid leaves, Kiela repairs the damage from the storm. The next day, she prepares to check in on the merbaby and Larran. The mermaid and her son have returned to the ocean, so she continues. When Larran doesn’t answer, Kiela imagines that he’s falling in love with the refugee woman. She goes to see Bryn instead and observes the carnage left by the storm. Tobin is helping but causing a mess. Kiela helps serve tea and overhears Larran and the new woman, Radane, talking on the terrace. Radane has come from Alyssium, just like Kiela, and tells the onlookers about the revolt there. Kiela runs away as she relives the trauma of her departure.
Kiela distracts herself by searching for a cure for Halio’s spring. She finds a book on storms and learns that a storm can be tamed by a “wind-speaker” and a group of sorcerers. Suddenly, she hears Caz and Larran talking and goes to join them. Larran asks for Kiela’s help healing Sian, who has been infected with the same storm sickness. Kiela gathers her spell ingredients and follows him. They discover Radane at Larran’s house; she shows an interest in Caz while Kiela attempts her healing spell out of sight. However, Radane spies on them and acts suspicious.
The next day, Kiela and Caz prepare to work on more tree growth spells. Three customers enter the shop: Bryn, Eadie, and a many-armed harpist named Ulina. They briefly discuss Kiela’s mother, whom Ulina was friends with at school. Bryn explains that they want to buy more tree remedies, and Kiela says that she’ll need to make more while they wait. Eadie offers to help, but Kiela is concerned that they’ll see her working illegal magic. In the end, Kiela decides to trust her new friends. They work on creating the spells together. Afterward, Eadie suggests that they name themselves the “Pine Cone Coven,” after the key ingredient. Kiela suggests “Pine Cone Society,” and they agree.
This section opens with a new addition to the scope of the story: the guardian forest spirits who take the form of bears and come to Kiela for help. They are briefly alluded to in the first chapter, when Kiela chooses “Examinations of the Function of Forest Spirits in Fact and Fiction” to bring with her on her journey (4). This plot device foreshadows this development and also provides exposition on background information of these creatures. Kiela’s contact with the otherworldly spirits of legend raises the stakes of the novel and pushes her into a situation in which she is largely over her head. The enormity of the task she’s given illuminates how the problems that the island is facing are much bigger than any one person—the landscape as a whole is dying. For Kiela, who spent so much of her life confined in the walls of the library, this presents a completely new way of thinking.
As tension rises in the community, Keila is presented with another challenge of the natural world: the ferocious storm that arises because of imbalanced magic. The storms in the novel occupy an unusual place on the spectrum of literary conflict. They fall under the “protagonist versus nature” conflict type, which normally refers to impersonal attacks from natural disasters or adverse conditions. In this context, however, the natural disaster is one directly created by the withdrawal of imperial support. Thus, it becomes a problem of classicism and social disorder, or the “protagonist versus society.” The first storm from Chapters 16-17 fills two purposes in moving the plot forward: It pushes Kiela and Larran closer together, and it introduces Radane to the narrative. Kiela realizes the depth of her growing feelings for him just as he’s at risk of being taken away. In these moments, Larran illustrates his deep-set caretaker instincts for both women, putting himself in danger for the well-being of others.
While Larran cares for Radane, Kiela is pushed into a caretaker situation of her own when a distraught mermaid arrives at her home. While Larran makes his rescue with physical strength and raw determination, Kiela uses her own unique skills: “She’d read about this—if a creature born of magic absorbed too much excess magic at once, it could overwhelm them” (199). It’s because of her knowledge as a librarian that she’s able to save an endangered child. Then, she uses this knowledge again to save Sian. The stakes presented in this scene are much higher, a natural progression of Kiela’s prior rescue since she’s aiding someone that means so much to Larran.
Following the storm, Kiela engages with the local women and makes a pivotal choice: She shares the secret of her tree remedies with them, despite the danger of exposure: “She wasn’t going to let a little fear keep her from doing what was right” (226). This decision underscores both The Value of Kinship and Community and the impact of Free Knowledge for the People. Kiela has realized how important these people are to her life now, and her way of providing support and care to them in return is to make the aid they need more accessible. Her choice also subtly parallels Larran’s; she risks personal harm to help others. This illustrates how Kiela is learning to exist as part of a supportive community after many years of adapting to being self-sufficient. Moreover, it shows how the skills learned within her self-imposed isolation are transferable and unexpectedly applicable to her new way of living. Through the power of books and learning—one of the novel’s most championed messages—Kiela can become a hero to those around her and affect real change.