logo

62 pages 2 hours read

Isabel Allende

The Stories of Eva Luna

Fiction | Short Story Collection | Adult | Published in 1989

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Themes

Language and Storytelling as Tools for Survival

In The Stories of Eva Luna, characters grapple with difficult circumstances including political unrest, war, abuse, and illness. As the characters navigate these challenges, Allende asserts that language and storytelling are tools for survival. More broadly, Eva Luna’s role as narrator and the motif of Eva as a modern Scheherazade reinforce the concept of storytelling as a coping mechanism.

In several instances, protagonists in The Stories of Eva Luna use creative language or storytelling to survive. A prominent example of this is Belisa Crepusculario in “Two Words,” the opening story of the collection. Belisa “[makes] her living selling words” (3), pulling herself out of poverty and building a profession that allows her to support herself and be independent. Even Belisa’s name is something that she crafted for herself: “[S]he herself had searched until she found the poetry of ‘beauty’ and ‘twilight’ and cloaked herself in it” (3). Through Belisa’s near-magical use of language to find her identity and establish her independence, Allende asserts that stories can be used to shape reality. In Belisa’s case, language enables her to make a name for herself and to develop a relationship with the powerful Colonel. Allende links her tale to real-life instances of revolutionary language and storytelling by using Belisa’s last name as an allusion to Pablo Neruda. The Chilean poet was also a politician who worked with President Salvador Allende to build a socialist, more egalitarian Chile and was likely assassinated after Pinochet’s coup in 1973. His first book of poetry was called Crepusculario, indicating that Belisa is also a changemaker who can use her words to create a better world.

Other stories in the collection are cautionary tales, where Allende explores what may happen if the use of language goes astray. Maurizia, the protagonist in “Tosca,” tells a story through her life choices, chasing an opera-worthy romance by having an affair and leaving her husband and son to start a new life. Maurizia imagines herself in grand stories, attributing romantic features to herself and her lover. For many years, this strategy of living in a story works for Maurizia; she finds happiness amid harsh conditions living in an oil camp and then builds a strong community of friends when she moves to Agua Santa. Yet, at the end of the story, Maurizia sees her estranged husband with her son and realizes “that the true hero of her dream was Ezio [...] She hesitated for an infinite moment on the borderline between reality and dream, then stepped back” (101). In the end, Maurizia’s lifelong storytelling leaves her alienated. It is not clear whether the narrator believes that Maurizia is continuing to live in a dream or if resisting contact with her ex-husband represents her reentry into reality. Either way, Maurizia’s experiences underscore the potency of storytelling; it can aid in survival or bring about destruction.

The collection of tales in The Stories of Eva Luna reinforces the concept of storytelling as a tool for survival because the narrator of most of the stories, Eva, uses them for that very purpose. Eva offers the stories to Rolf to help him process his trauma and move forward into a positive future. Stories are the mechanism that Eva uses to bring hope and optimism into her world and her relationship. She finishes her stories to Rolf with this thought: “I know that when you return from your nightmares, we shall again walk hand in hand” (270). After these words, Allende includes a closing epigraph: “And at this moment in her story, Scheherazade saw the first light of dawn, and discreetly fell silent” (270). These closing lines solidify the motif of Eva as Scheherazade, a character who saves her life (and the lives of others) by telling stories. As such, Allende uses the story collection to reinforce the concept of stories as life-saving.

The Resilience of Women

The Stories of Eva Luna is peopled with resilient women who overcome adversity, often out of sheer force of will. Throughout her body of work, Allende celebrates strong women, and she continues that trend in this collection. Allende explores the reality of a Latin American patriarchal society and investigates the resiliency that is required of women to survive and thrive within its bounds.

Casilda Hidalgo of “The Judge’s Wife” is a reserved yet resilient character. Casilda, though gentle and quiet, is credited with motivating her harsh, corrupt husband to become more empathetic and equitable with his rulings. She confronts her husband in front of their whole town to stop the torture of Juana la Triste. The depth of Casilda’s resilience is evident in her actions at the end of the story when she “must do something much more difficult than die slowly” to protect her children (154). Despite her fear, the recent death of her husband, and her worry for her children, she boldly looks Nicolás Vidal in the eye and offers her body to him in exchange for her children’s safety. Her quiet boldness and resilient spirit pay off; in addition to her safety, she is rewarded with the most satisfying sexual experience of her life. As such, her story is not only a celebration of women’s strength and sacrifice but their sexuality as well.

Allende is particularly interested in sex’s role in women’s empowerment. Story 11, “Simple María” features a female protagonist who, like many other protagonists in this collection, finds meaning and power through sex (and sex work in particular). María’s resilience manifests in a straightforward optimism; until the day she dies, María “live[s] in expectation of the moment that the curtain to her room would open” to admit the sailor she fell in love with years ago (130). María approaches life with hope and enthusiasm despite experiencing many tragedies. Her life story demonstrates the harsh restrictions of a patriarchal society: After her accident, she marries a man much her senior and is later sent to Spain against her will. The only way that María can exert her independence is by running away from her family and becoming a sex worker, work at which she excels because she can create loving experiences for her clients. Her resilient hopefulness is an attribute that Eva Luna admires; as she narrates María’s story, she uses flattering words like “delicacy,” “consideration” and “uncompromising love” to describe her (129-30), subverting typical narratives and ideas about sex work. Through the remarkable story of María’s life, and Eva’s admiration, Allende, celebrates the way women can stand up to the restrictiveness of a patriarchal society.

The Power of Sexuality and Desire

The Stories of Eva Luna is a sensuous collection in which Allende asserts that sexuality and desire are essential aspects of the human experience. In exploring the sexual desires of her female characters, Allende also investigates the way female sexual expression is vital in subverting patriarchal norms.

The “Wicked Girl” follows the budding sexuality of a young woman, Elena. At the beginning of the story, Elena is “scrawny” and “unnoticed.” She is on the verge of puberty when Juan José Bernal arrives to stay in the hotel that Elena’s mother runs. Attracted by Bernal’s sensuality, his talent as a musician, and his expressiveness, Elena experiences an internal transformation. She becomes impassioned and obsessive, heated with a desire to explore her own body and Bernal’s. Elena’s awakening sensuality makes her feel more alive, and she becomes more curious about the world. The story is complicated by the fact that Elena is a child and Bernal is an adult. When she attempts to engage in sexual activities with him, he pushes her away because of her age. Still, the memory of her passion and desire leaves a lasting mark on him, and he struggles with shameful feelings for years afterward. The power of sexuality is evident in the way it enables Elena to become a more robust, present version of herself, as well as the way her desire marks Bernal for life. This indicates that while sexuality and desire are natural and should be celebrated, they should also be used judiciously so as not to harm others. This is reinforced in other stories, which recount the lifelong impacts of sexual assault and rape.

In writing about the power of sexuality and desire, Allende investigates the way female desire in particular can subvert and undermine patriarchal power structures. “Toad’s Mouth” is arguably the most sexual of the stories in the collection. The protagonist—and by far the most powerful character in the tale—is Hermelinda, who uses her sexuality to make a living, inventing “games of fantasy” to play with the workers of Sheepbreeders, Ltd (42). Hermelinda is a sex worker and an entertainer, and she thrives in her work: “[S]he laughed with gusto and had grit to spare [...] In every embrace, however brief, she proved herself an enthusiastic and playful friend” (44). In a society dominated by rich men, Hermelinda leverages her creativity and sexuality to build a life for herself with more independence than many of the other women in the collection. The end of the story has Hermelinda riding off with her new love interest, whom she seems passionate about. The man is drawn to her because of her reputation as an excellent sex worker, and even though Hermelinda partners up in the end, Allende asserts that it is her sexuality and desire that bring her this satisfying relationship.

“Our Secret,” a story about a brief, passionate encounter between two strangers, highlights the way intimacy brought about by female sexuality can build strong social connections. After the male character in the story becomes distracted by memories of the war, he is unable to continue their sexual intimacy and pulls away. The female character, still engaged in the moment and also wanting to comfort him, holds him and touches him gently. When she sees his pain and confusion, she reveals that she, too, experienced trauma at the hands of the dictatorial regime. This revelation, brought about by intimacy and sharing her body with him, leads them to discover a powerful sense of togetherness. Their sexuality and desire help them overcome the scars left by a brutal political conflict. With this, Allende asserts that love—in all of its forms—is powerful enough to heal national and political trauma.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text