logo

43 pages 1 hour read

Tarryn Fisher

The Wrong Family

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 2020

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Part 3, Chapters 20-25Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Part 3

Part 3, Chapter 20 Summary: “Winnie”

The Crouch family all get sick, which Winnie blames on Dulce, thinking that her germs were on the whiskey bottle. Dakota texts Winnie telling her that he’s been staying with their mother and begging Winnie to intervene on his behalf with his wife, Manda. Nigel has been sleeping in the den since the confrontation about Dulce but brings Winnie water and toast in bed while she’s sick, showing he still cares. Shelly invites Winnie and her family to her cabin for Christmas break, but Nigel can’t go because of a work conference. Winnie decides to go, taking along the marijuana that Dakota brought her back when he was living with them.

Part 3, Chapter 21 Summary: “Juno”

Juno reminisces about her mother’s beauty salon, called The Slick. Her mother, Hoida Pearl, would gossip with the ladies who came to get their hair done, and they would ask Juno to leave the room so that they could speak freely. Juno would sneak around so that she could listen to all the stories. She plans to use those skills now. There have been angry voicemails on the family phone from Dakota, but Nigel erased them without telling Winnie about them.

Trapped in the crawl space during the Crouches’ sickness, Juno spends a lot of time thinking about her past: She was in prison, and no one would help her when she left. Her husband and stepsons were gone, and no one, even her old friend Bette, would tell her where they went. Juno had been convicted of fourth degree criminal sexual misconduct, intentional affliction of emotional distress, and sexual harassment by a professional for (among other things) having an affair with a client to whom she was providing marital counseling.

When the Crouches leave for the cabin, Juno has the house to herself. She finds the name Josalyn Russel in the family computer’s search history, leading her to an article about a pregnant girl who disappeared.

Part 3, Chapter 22 Summary: “Winnie”

Winnie thought she would feel better at the cabin, but she feels terrible wherever she is. She has only told Nigel half Josalyn’s story. Josalyn had bipolar disorder and a substance use disorder, and she ran away from home at 18; Winnie used these details to paint Josalyn as a “villain.” However, after gaining Josalyn’s trust with snacks, Winnie learned that Josalyn had been molested by her stepfather and his friends and that she started using drugs to cope with the trauma.

When Josalyn got pregnant, she insisted on keeping her baby, even though she lived in a tent and was selling sex to get drugs. Winnie eventually received a voicemail from Josalyn asking for help and giving Winnie her location. She found Josalyn and the baby in terrible conditions and believed that Josalyn had died: “The smell of death was so present that Winnie’s eyes had immediately gone to the baby and stayed there. The child was her priority; the child had not asked to be put in this dire situation” (205). Winnie climbed back to her car with the baby and drove away instead of calling an ambulance.

Part 3, Chapter 23 Summary: “Juno”

Juno deliberately breaks the cable box to mess with Nigel’s mind. She finds $500, a condom, and a credit card in Nigel’s gym bag, which was left in Hem’s Corner. She keeps $25 and pokes a hole in the condom before returning the things. Nigel calls a cable repairman about the box, and Juno heads out of the house, knowing the Crouches have left the alarm off so the repairman can come.

Juno goes to the park and finds Sam, who recognizes her T-shirt. Juno says she picked it up from Goodwill, but she actually took it from a donation bag inside the house. Sam buys them both hot dogs from the kiosk, and Juno buys him some Froot Loops, a forbidden food in his household but one of his favorites. Juno observes to Sam, “Unfortunately, we aren’t the only ones in charge of our story arcs. Outsiders have an influence, too” (216).

Juno could leave the house now that winter is over and go back to living in the park, but she wants to save Sam. She decides to investigate the Russel family.

Part 3, Chapter 24 Summary: “Winnie”

Winnie notices that Sam has Froot Loops but decides not to say anything even though she really doesn’t want him to eat sugar. She asks him to walk around the lake and he agrees. However, he refuses to talk and engage with her.

During the walk, Manda calls and tells Winnie that Dakota has been making threats. Manda insists, “God, I know how you guys worship your brother, but he’s not been right for a while. No one wants to acknowledge that” (225). Dakota thinks he saw a ghost in Winnie’s house and is drunk most of the time. Manda warns that Dakota has it out for her husband. Winnie wonders what’s going on with Sam and if he knows anything.

Part 3, Chapter 25 Summary: “Juno”

Juno locates Josalyn Russel’s obituary, which is very distant in tone. Juno calls the Russels using Winnie’s home phone. Lying that she knew Josalyn at Illuminations, Juno uses her “loss” of her stepsons to ingratiate herself with Terry Russel on the phone. Juno asks for Terry’s email address, saying she has something important to tell her.

Part 3, Chapters 20-25 Analysis

The truth about The Weight of Secrets that has plagued Winnie from the beginning of the novel is slowly beginning to emerge. Chapter 22 confirms that Winnie took a baby, encouraging the reader to suspect that Sam was that baby. This is another red herring. By giving readers incomplete information about what happened, Fisher is able to maintain suspense and heighten the impact of eventual plot twists. As much as The Illusion of Perfection clouds people’s understanding of how difficult Winnie’s life currently is, the tangled reality of her past is equally misleading. The way in which Fisher reveals information also places readers in a position analogous to Juno’s, developing the idea that there is something voyeuristic about the thriller genre.

The new details that emerge about Juno’s professional past underscore the moral ambiguity of The Role of the Observer. Juno’s involvement in her patients’ lives reached such an unethical degree that she went to prison and lost her family. Yet Juno is engaging in those same behaviors with the Crouch family by sending the news clippings and otherwise tormenting Winnie. She even tries to upset the broader family dynamics: Poking a hole in Nigel’s condom could lead to an unplanned pregnancy with Dulce, and breaking the cable box is a deliberate attempt to wreak havoc in the family. Juno claims that creating a chaotic atmosphere will facilitate her search for information; she also wants to bring Winnie to justice. However, these rationalizations fail to explain the full spectrum of Juno’s behavior, which is often harmful not only to others but also to herself. Her memories of her mother’s beauty parlor reveal just how deeply rooted her need to interfere in other peoples’ lives is, bolstering the idea that there is something uncontrollable about the urge. Her interactions with Sam are even more telling in that they closely mirror Winnie’s past behavior toward Josalyn and her baby. Like Winnie, Juno plies a vulnerable teenager with treats to gain their trust. She also justifies her behavior on the grounds that Sam is living in a bad environment, much as Winnie did when she kidnapped Josalyn’s child. Juno’s inability to recognize the parallels between herself and Winnie underscores the extent to which obsession and selfishness rather than empathy drive her actions.  

Dakota’s alcohol use disorder serves as a more literal counterpart to the addictive behavioral patterns of characters like Juno and Winnie. Once again, however, the characters themselves fail to note the similarities. Noting that Dakota has been experiencing a mental illness for quite some time, Manda points out that “[n]o one wants to acknowledge that” (225). By insisting that all is well in the family, Winnie has ignored several warning signs that all is not right with her brother. Manda’s call foreshadows the events that will happen at the end of the novel.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text