logo

40 pages 1 hour read

Louise Levathes

When China Ruled the Seas

Nonfiction | Biography | Adult | Published in 1994

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Prologue-Chapter 3Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Prologue Summary: “Phantoms in Silk”

In 1418, in the East African coastal city of Malindi in what is today Kenya, an impressive armada of ships appeared on the horizon, which the observers on the beach first took to be storm clouds. In fact, the “clouds” were giant sails on the massive ships. Totaling almost a hundred ships, the armada included supplies, water tanks, horses for a cavalry, and thousands of soldiers. The largest cargo ships were 400 feet in length and equipped with nine masts. This was the Chinese treasure fleet, commanded by Admiral Zheng He, which sailed from China through the Indian Ocean as far as Africa seven times between 1405 and 1433.

As Levathes explains, China under the newly established Ming dynasty “extended its sphere of political power and influence throughout the Indian Ocean” and was poised to “become the great colonial power, a hundred years before the great age of European exploration and expansion” (20). Then it ceased its sea voyages and retreated into isolation as quickly as it expanded. This allowed the West to catch up and surpass China technologically, leading to a very different outcome than the one contemporaries might have imagined in the early 15th century. 

Chapter 1 Summary: “The Yi Peoples”

This first chapter covers the earliest recorded history of China through the Han dynasty and explains how geography shaped the different peoples’ relationship with the sea. Mountains separated the inland people from those on the coast. Known as the Yi, the coastal people were divided into Eastern and Southern groups, both of which had to rely on the sea rather than large-scale agriculture for food. The Southern group traveled to the islands of what is now Indonesia and as far south as modern-day Australia, while the Eastern group crossed the Bering Strait—then connected by land—into North America.

As the glaciers of the last Ice Age receded and melted, rising seas forced another series of migrations from the southern coast of China. The Southern Yi reached Taiwan and the Philippines before heading farther to Pacific islands such as Fiji. They improved techniques and added elements to the design of boats, like rudders and sails for better control. These innovations allowed Southeast Asians to reach as far west as Madagascar and as far east, scholars believe, as the Americas. If the latter proves true, it would be the first contact there by people from Asia. Aspects of Indigenous culture in the Americas, like boat design and techniques for making bark from clothes, are so similar that Levathes believes the Asian seafarers introduced them.

Meanwhile, the cultures of the Eastern Yi people and inland peoples combined around 1500 BC to form the Shang dynasty, which ended when the Zhou people it five hundred years later. Some scholars think survivors of the Shang fled south, mixed with the Southern Yi, and set off across the sea toward the Americas. As the author writes, “Mysteriously and unexpectedly, out of primitive societies without highly developed arts, two highly sophisticated civilizations took root in the New World as the Shang empire was crumbling” (28). These include handiwork in jade in a Mexican area that did not have this tradition as part of its culture. Such evidence points to Asian influence in parts of Central and South America.

After a period of warring in China, the Qin dynasty unified much of the country in 221 BC Many legends during this period refer to sea travel, often involving the Qin emperor’s search for herbs in a faraway land rumored make one immortal. Some cultural similarities between China and the Mayan civilization in Central America point to the possibility of more contact in the New World during this time and again later in the fifth century. 

Chapter 2 Summary: “Confucians and Curiosities”

This chapter discusses the development of seafaring in China from the Han dynasty in the second century BC to the Yuan dynasty, which lasted until 1368 A.D. During the Han period, the philosophy of Confucius became prominent among the rulers and laid the groundwork for the budding bureaucracy. Born centuries earlier in 551 BC, Confucius viewed trade as lowly, below agriculture and civil service. Likewise, he discouraged travel because it interfered with carrying out family obligations at home. Moreover, many believed that beyond the borders of China lived only barbaric peoples. These two ideas would have a strong influence on later dynasties.

When the Tang dynasty rose to the height of its power in the seventh century, its capital Chang’an—today called Xi’an—was the largest and most diverse city in the world. It was the starting point of the famed Silk Road, a series of trade routes that went deep into Central Asia. Traders from all over came to sell their wares, making the city a cultural melting pot and influencing the fashions and social mores of the Chinese. Just as silk dominated the trade overland, Chinese porcelain was the focus of sea trade out of the southern city of Guangzhou.

The Song dynasty saw the next extended period of sea travel. Because of strong attacks from the north, the court retreated south to establish a capital at Hangzhou in 1127. The decreased geographical area under Song control meant less revenue from taxes, and “[n]ecessity,” Levathes writes, “demanded a reexamination of Confucian texts to put trade and profit into a more favorable light” (41). The emperor built up a fleet of trading ships to challenge Arab and Persian dominance in the Indian Ocean. Hangzhou grew rich from trade and culturally diverse, much as Chang’an had during the Tang dynasty.

In the capital’s southern location, the Yangzi River to the north and the sea to the east and south became part of the dynasty’s defense system. Accordingly, the Song also created a strong navy and developed innovative ship designs. They used paddle wheels for greater maneuverability and catapults to send gunpowder bombs onto enemy ships. Despite these great advantages, the Mongols to the north captured the Song after Song defectors helped them build their own powerful navy.

Led by Khubilai “Kublai” Khan, the Mongols declared the Yuan dynasty in 1271. The khan, Levathes notes, was a powerful, insatiable ruler who used his formidable navy to sail the waters of much of Asia. He invaded Japan twice, succeeding in battle both times until typhoons destroyed much of his armada. According to some accounts, he sent ships as far as Madagascar. As he rebuilt the Grand Canal, the main route for southern crops to reach Beijing, he handed over control of this commerce to two merchants who used alternative routes along the coast. The merchants, however, stole from the state and accepted gifts from foreign representatives. For this, they were put to death. But the incident pointed to the decline of the Yuan dynasty, which fell to the Ming by the end of the 14th century.

Chapter 3 Summary: “The Prisoner and the Prince”

Born in 1371 shortly after the fall of the Yuan dynasty, Zheng He was captured as boy by Ming forces in Yunnan, castrated, and sent to Beijing as one of the eunuchs assigned to serve Prince Zhu Di, one of the sons of the new Ming emperor, Zhu Yuanzhang. The two became close, and Zheng accompanied Zhu Di on his first successful military campaign in 1390 to subdue a renegade Mongol leader.

When the emperor’s eldest son died, he took the advice of his Confucian advisors to make his 14-year-old grandson, Zhu Yunwen, his heir. The advisors believed this would avoid conflict among his remaining sons who might disagree with whichever other brother their father chose. The emperor, however, wanted Zhu Di to succeed him, and it was clear to all that he was more capable and possessed greater leadership than the chosen grandson. This set up an almost inevitable clash between the two.

When Zhu Yuanzhang died in 1398, protracted fighting between Zhu Di and Zhu Yunwen lasted until 1402, when the prince finally defeated his nephew. Inside the gates of the capital city of Nanjing, the victors found three badly burned bodies. Though they assumed one of the bodies belonged to Zhu Yunwen, it was burned beyond recognition. Thus, rumors lasted throughout Zhu Di’s reign that his nephew escaped and was biding his time until he could regain the throne. 

Prologue-Chapter 3 Analysis

In these early chapters, Levathes establishes the fact that China was a sea power from early in its history, one of the main themes of the book. She reviews the evidence for this to show that by the early centuries AD, the Chinese already traveled far and wide, leaving their influence on other cultures. As the author writes, “Whatever became of the Han seafarers at the dawn of the Christian era, China even at this very early point cannot be dismissed as a land-based power with no interest in the sea” (32).

Levathes also introduces another main theme that runs throughout the book: the tension between Confucian scholar-officials and other elements of Chinese society over the issue of trade. Confucian philosophy, which looked down on commerce and favored agriculture, took hold in pockets of the government. Like many ideas, it led to a heated debate over time by adherents and opponents. This is seen during the Tang and Song dynasties, both of which supported an active trading environment. It was an issue that would play out again in the Ming dynasty with great consequences. Levathes sees this as central to Chinese thinking: “At the heart of the matter is China’s view of itself and its position in the world, which has changed little to the present day. Today there is still the same ambiguity toward foreigners and foreign influence. The opening and closing of doors” (21).

Interestingly, the years following the publication of Levathes’ book saw the ebb and flow of China’s trade relations with the rest of the world turn away from isolationism anew. According to the Cato Institute, a 2000 U.S. law granting “permanent normal trade relations” between the two countries caused Chinese imports to spike over the next decade. Some critics of the law suggest that it also caused the U.S. to lose 2.4 million jobs. (Lincicome, Scott. “Testing the ‘China Shock’: Was Normalizing Trade with China a Mistake?” Cato Institute. 8 Jul. 2020.) In 2020, this trend may reverse again—not because of internal philosophical or ideological forces as before but because of the COVID-19 pandemic, combined with the policies of President Donald Trump. According to the Brookings Institution, this state of affairs hurts both China and its trade partners like the United States. (Hass, Ryan. “More pain than gain: How the US-China trade war hurt America.” Brookings. 7 Aug. 2020. https://www.brookings.edu/blog/order-from-chaos/2020/08/07/more-pain-than-gain-how-the-us-china-trade-war-hurt-america/.)

Chapter 3 sets the scene for the heart of the book with the ascension to the throne of Zhu Di and his trusted eunuch aide, Zheng He. The main characters in the narrative, Zhu Di and Zheng He are central to the voyages of the treasure fleet. Levathes also explains how eunuchs became proponents of trade and the rivals of the Confucian scholars at court. Already, the author foreshadows the continued strife over the trade issue by describing Zhu Di’s father, the founder of the Ming dynasty, as wary of outside influences, while Zhu Di was ready to open the empire and show off its grandeur.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text