logo

63 pages 2 hours read

Ariel Lawhon, Kristina McMorris, Susan Meissner

When We Had Wings

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 2023

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Part 3Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Part 3: “1943”

Part 3, Chapter 14 Summary: “Penny”

Santo Tomas Internment Camp, Manila, May 1943

Penny confesses to Eleanor that she kissed Charley Russell and feels guilty for betraying her husband. Eleanor says he would want her to be happy, but Penny says it would be too much for her to lose two men in one lifetime. She confides in Eleanor about her daughter’s death.

The camp is full of “war orphans,” children who were separated from their living parents. Newt, a 10-year-old girl, follows Penny everywhere. Penny tries to resist but can’t help caring for the “incorrigible delight.” However, she’s upset when she learns that Newt is a pickpocket who steals from the Japanese guards.

Laura Cobb volunteered the Navy nurses to help set up a new internment camp, so Eleanor is leaving again. She and Penny agree that everyone must follow orders, even though Eleanor and the other Navy nurses feel that the government abandoned them during the evacuation of Manila.

After bidding Eleanor goodbye, Penny returns to her quarters to find Lieutenant Akibo. He proposes that she become his mistress in exchange for food and supplies. He warns that if she doesn’t agree, she and her friends (including Newt) will suffer because she has no power. Penny says she would rather have no power than no honor.

Part 3, Chapter 15 Summary: “Eleanor”

Los Baños Prison Camp, Laguna Province, May 1943

Nurses and soldiers are transported by cattle car and then made to walk through the jungle. Japanese officers refuse them water. When they reach the grounds of the former school that will become the camp, they’re led to a baseball field, where they’re left to sleep on the ground with mosquitoes swarming. Eleanor knows that there’s no use in pointing out that this violates the Geneva Convention.

The camp has few supplies, so the nurses make do by repurposing anything they can scavenge. They barter their medical expertise with the Japanese for other resources. Rumors spread that they’ve been hidden away for use as a bargaining chip when the Americans arrive, and Eleanor tries not to imagine what life would be like if the Japanese won the war. Only thoughts of home and John Olson comfort her.

A new civilian American doctor arrives, Dr. Nance. He’s immediately called upon to help an ailing Japanese man. When he diagnoses appendicitis and the Japanese commandant wants to transport him to a real hospital, the doctor warns that he’ll die without immediate treatment. They agree to let him operate but say they’ll kill one of the nurses if the patient dies. The surgery is successful, but Laura Cobb warns the doctor that he must never again put her nurses at risk.

Part 3, Chapter 16 Summary: “Lita”

Manila, June 1943

Lita and Reyna work as civilian nurses at Philippine General Hospital. Lita overhears a Japanese soldier, Kenji Yamada, mumbling in English as he wakes from anesthesia, though he claims to speak only Japanese. She tricks Yamada into revealing that he understands English. He confesses that he’s “nisei,” or second generation, and was born in Canada to Japanese parents. His family had just returned to Japan when the war broke out and he was drafted. Lita asks how he can fight fellow Canadians, but he points out how Canada and the US have treated Japanese civilians: The government “rounded them up and stuck them in some filthy camp behind barbed wire” (220) after Japan bombed Pearl Harbor. He begs Lita not to tell anyone his secret, and she promises not to.

A Filipino priest, Father Domingo, arrives looking for Dr. Alvarez, who isn’t there. Lita greets him, and he explains that he works with the Resistance; Santo Tomas needs medical supplies, and he asks Lita to smuggle for him. She agrees.

On their way home, Lita and Reyna see Dr. Alvarez on a platform in the street. He’s publicly executed by the Kempeitai, the Japanese military police, for collaborating with the Resistance. Knowing that she could meet the same fate by helping Father Domingo, Lita is terrified.

Part 3, Chapter 17 Summary: “Penny”

Santo Tomas Internment Camp, July 1943

The nurses are assigned a new living space, where Akibo is less likely to bother Penny. However, she wonders whether she’ll eventually be forced to accept his proposition to protect herself and Newt from the growing chaos in the camp. Newt brings news: The soldiers say that Commandant Tsurumi, who oversees the camp with “benign neglect,” is being replaced. The new commander, Kodaki, won’t be as forgiving.

Care packages arrive, and a man delivers a bag of coconuts to Penny. In a hollow coconut she finds a letter from Charley and a wad of cash. He and other officers found a stash of money while working to rebuild Malinta Tunnel for the Japanese, and he says he hopes it can do her some good, reiterating his promise to come back and claim a kiss. She realizes with gratitude that this will enable her to continue getting the things she and Newt need without Akibo.

Blanche Kimball is being transferred to Philippine General Hospital due to malaria, and Penny is her escort. In Blanche’s room, Penny sees her deck of cards and impulsively cuts it in half, revealing the eight of hearts. She puts the card in her pocket, where it will stay for the rest of the war.

On the way to the hospital, Father Domingo tells Penny that he requested her as Blanche’s escort because a friend told him that Penny is a person to trust; he asks if she’s willing to help move messages and money into camp. She agrees.

Part 3, Chapter 18 Summary: “Lita”

Philippine General Hospital, July 1943

Lita and Penny reunite. Knowing that Penny is working with Father Domingo, Lita feels she can fully commit to the cause. The women make plans to meet each other twice a week at the package line. In the meantime, Lita sends notes of encouragement to Lon at Bilibid to keep his spirits up. Father Domingo tells her Lon has been badly beaten and arranges to have her accompany a doctor to the prison so that she can visit him. After hours of surgeries, the priest takes Lita to Lon’s cell to “confirm his healing” (224). During their brief reunion, Lita makes Lon promise to get well and survive. She tells him that she loves him.

Part 3, Chapter 19 Summary: “Eleanor”

Los Baños Prison Camp, Laguna Province, October 1943

Eleanor is alarmed by the little news she hears from incoming prisoners and from a makeshift radio. Italy has surrendered, but the Japanese have executed POWs at Wake Island. She wishes for the simple pleasures of home.

Part 3 Analysis

These chapters mark multiple transitions as the nurses adapt to life in the Japanese-occupied Philippines. Denied any true freedoms, each finds purpose through caring for others and resisting in small ways. The pace of events slows somewhat as routines are established and the characters make consequential decisions, while the motif of promises emphasizes both the power and fragility of their personal connections in such circumstances.

By incorporating historical details about conditions at the camps and the hospital under Japanese occupation, the novel continues to thematically interrogate The Untold Roles of Women in History, connecting this idea to the novel’s themes about loyalty and personal connections. Though Penny and Eleanor’s friendship is among the “few comforts in this strange new reality” (176), Eleanor doesn’t hesitate to follow Laura Cobb’s orders and go with the other nurses to Los Baños, saying, “I’m Navy” in a way that conveys loyalty to her duties and the promise she made when she enlisted. Penny’s thinking sums this up: “Eleanor had chosen to face hardship, to follow Laura’s orders without question. They both knew she could be walking into the mouth of hell. But how much more noble to do that than to run away from it?” (178-79). Penny’s pride in her friend is constrained somewhat by the feeling of weariness from continually losing people, demonstrating the toll that the nurses’ dedication to honor and duty takes on them.

Eleanor’s decision to follow orders isolates her in the jungle for the remainder of the novel, and this mirrors her figurative retreat inward: Her only comforts are memories of John Olson and her family’s dairy farm. Conversely, Penny and Lita make consequential decisions that connect them with one another and the world. Through their smuggling work with Father Domingo and the support they receive from Charley and Lon, each thematically demonstrates The Power of Hope and Personal Connection and makes discoveries about her own capacity for courage. This is most apparent in Lita’s decision to smuggle supplies despite witnessing the execution of Dr. Alvarez and in Penny’s love for Newt despite her sense of inadequacy as a mother.

In sending the three protagonists on these diverging paths, the novel augments a realistic exploration of wartime experiences and explores the nature of shared humanity. While descriptions of brutality, deprivation, and defiance of the Geneva Convention use broad strokes to paint Japanese forces as the enemy, Lita’s conversation with Yamada and Dr. Nance’s compassion toward his Japanese patient offer a more nuanced look at the humanity and impact of individual choices. The conditions under occupation emphasize what little control the women have over their own lives; through the choices they make about how to go about their duties and maintain personal connections, they sustain hope.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text